Mid season award winners

Also Rios has committed 7 less erros than Miguel.

[jonumberone]

Originally Posted by ChicagoWhiteSox

Also Rios has committed 7 less erros than Miguel.

One is an outfieldser and one is a first baseman. Thats like saying Alex rios should win the Cy Young because he has 5 less wild pitches than David Price.

Originally Posted by jonumberone

One is an outfieldser and one is a first baseman. Thats like saying Alex rios should win the Cy Young because he has 5 less wild pitches than David Price.

Not at all. We are talking Al Mvp here. That makes every position player eligible right? I'm just comparing two position players.

[jonumberone]

Originally Posted by ChicagoWhiteSox

Not at all. We are talking Al Mvp here. That makes every position player eligible right? I'm just comparing two position players.

You are right, not a fair comparison. However comparing the fielding stats of an infielder with an outfielder is just as unfair.
Rios is having a great year, as is swisher. Just think in this supposed year of the pitcher Cabrera is having a Monster year. Seasons only half over, and there is still plenty of time for him to get drunk, punch his wife and help his team miss the playoffs again, but at the half way mark Cabrera is the man.

Originally Posted by jonumberone

You are right, not a fair comparison. However comparing the fielding stats of an infielder with an outfielder is just as unfair.
Rios is having a great year, as is swisher. Just think in this supposed year of the pitcher Cabrera is having a Monster year. Seasons only half over, and there is still plenty of time for him to get drunk, punch his wife and help his team miss the playoffs again, but at the half way mark Cabrera is the man.

Cabrera hit his wife? I hope thats a joke.