Key West

[Blueface]

Originally Posted by chachee52

Ok, so we just spent a few hours looking at a bunch of places that you guy suggested, as well as others we found. We have a delema though now. Our favorite so far is Parrot Key: on the beach, relatively cheap but it's a little over 2 miles from town.
The pier is also catching our eye: on the beach, but water view is a little over our budget so we'd get teh regular room, right at the end of Deval St. and looks really nice.
Or La Concha: right in the middle of everything, but not on the water.
So now we just have to weigh our options out and see what is more important to us.
Thanks for all the help so far!!!

I have stayed regularly at two of the three you list.
The Pier House is nice. Wife loved it. Has a small man made beach, tiki bar, nice overall Keys like atmosphere.

The La Concha is so, so neat. Really cool looking interior with a throwback feel. The rooms are very nice with an old vintage look also. The property has a bar on the roof for sunset viewing. It has a very small pool but neat as it is located on a roof top also but 3rd or 4th floor - don't remember now as was too drunk on mojitos. BTW, they have awesome mojitos there. A few drinks and sunset on that rooftop will be memorable for sure.

Both of those are awesome. The fact that La Concha is not on the water would not bother me as in exchange, you are dead center on Duval. Key West is not known for beaches anyway.

Either of these, you cannot go wrong and will absolutely love it.