Toasting the foot: is it really necessary?

[Porch Dweller]

Opinions vary. I smoke outside so have to deal with the breeze when lighting, thus use a torch. I toast when I can, but sometimes I have to get the flame up close and personal to get it lit. Either way, I don't notice any difference as long as it's evenly lit and fully burning (like Rick, I blow gently on the end to make sure the whole foot is lit).

It's funny the opinions that people have about lighting a cigar. I get FSS posts in my Facebook and once there was a picture of a guy lighting a box-pressed cigar. He had a torch right up to the foot and there was flame all around it. Some of the comments from people were ridiculous. Many were in the vein of "Well that cigar is completely ruined!" It was Churchill sized, I think a little purge after it was lit and it would be just fine. My favorite exchange was someone said "Might as well throw it out and grab a new one" to which someone responded "Do it anyway, it's box-pressed so no loss." The cigar was a Padron 1926.

[Ashcan Bill]

I'll toast the foot on rare occasions just for grins, but usually I just apply fire and draw on it in a strong manly way to get her started. I've used wood matches, paper matches, soft flames, hard flames, cedar strips, and blazing branches from camp fires. I've reached the conclusion that the lighting method has zero influence on my ultimate enjoyment of the cigar. The only truth I've discovered through sad experience is that you never, ever attempt to light anything you find stuck in your mouth while riding in a top down convertible if you sport a moustache. This is an inviolatable truth.

As far as the method of lighting affecting the burn, if you don't get the complete foot lit than obviously you'll likely have a problem. But some cigars are just fated to burn in a way to irritate you. Doesn't matter how well you've cared for them, loved them or lit them - they're possessed.

[Oshay]

[Oshay]

Originally Posted by Ashcan Bill

I'll toast the foot on rare occasions just for grins, but usually I just apply fire and draw on it in a strong manly way to get her started. I've used wood matches, paper matches, soft flames, hard flames, cedar strips, and blazing branches from camp fires. I've reached the conclusion that the lighting method has zero influence on my ultimate enjoyment of the cigar. The only truth I've discovered through sad experience is that you never, ever attempt to light anything you find stuck in your mouth while riding in a top down convertible if you sport a moustache. This is an inviolatable truth.

As far as the method of lighting affecting the burn, if you don't get the complete foot lit than obviously you'll likely have a problem. But some cigars are just fated to burn in a way to irritate you. Doesn't matter how well you've cared for them, loved them or lit them - they're possessed.

[icehog3]

Originally Posted by Oshay

Originally Posted by Oshay

Shoot for three?