And the #1 cigar of the year is......

[Simple1]

I would agree as well. Consistent flavors and always enjoyable. But this is the same list that has a Gurkha in the top 10......

[pnoon]

Originally Posted by Simple1

I would agree as well. Consistent flavors and always enjoyable. But this is the same list that has a Gurkha in the top 10......

I disagree.
While the Monte 2 is a classic Cuban cigar and mind-blowing when they are on, I find them to be very inconsistent in quality.

My and worth half as much.

[EricF]

Originally Posted by pnoon

I disagree.
While the Monte 2 is a classic Cuban cigar and mind-blowing when they are on, I find them to be very inconsistent in quality.

My and worth half as much.

What Peter said.

[yourchoice]

Originally Posted by pnoon

I disagree.
While the Monte 2 is a classic Cuban cigar and mind-blowing when they are on, I find them to be very inconsistent in quality.

My and worth half as much.

Peter's statement is what I believe to be the general consensus, but I have been lucky with the couple of boxes I acquired.

[RobR1205]

Originally Posted by pnoon

I disagree.
While the Monte 2 is a classic Cuban cigar and mind-blowing when they are on, I find them to be very inconsistent in quality

Agree. First couple I smoked from my box were great, but I'm resting them after a couple of less than impressive sticks a year later.

[bruceolee]

Originally Posted by pnoon

I disagree.
While the Monte 2 is a classic Cuban cigar and mind-blowing when they are on, I find them to be very inconsistent in quality.

My and worth half as much.

I have to agree with you Peter. I don't hate Monte #2's but cigar of the year? Kind of a safe choice if you ask me.