The Bourbon Thread!!

[icehog3]

Originally Posted by bruceolee

My half-brother visited his grandfather and brought me back this and it's almost a shame because it's a 68' Decanter of 4 roses, apparently it's his old "go to" bourbon. what's sad is i don't drink due to my health.

Be a nice pour to offer any bourbon enthusiast friends who come over, Jason.

[bruceolee]

Originally Posted by icehog3

Be a nice pour to offer any bourbon enthusiast friends who come over, Jason.

Anytime bother. Anytime

[icehog3]

I cracked the newest Booker's (21-04, Noe Strangers), then had a pour of the previous (21-03, Bardstown). I like both better than any batch since 2019, and give the Strangers the slight edge based on just 1 pour. I'll revisit in a few weeks.

[Beagleone]

This this up yesterday...



And these over the weekend...

[icehog3]

Killed my 2018 Pinhook High Proof, and cracked the 2021.

[jledou]

Originally Posted by icehog3

Killed my 2018 Pinhook High Proof, and cracked the 2021.

I have the 2021 coming - should be here on Monday. What are your thoughts Tom?

[icehog3]

Originally Posted by jledou

I have the 2021 coming - should be here on Monday. What are your thoughts Tom?

Jay, I've liked all the high proof stuff from Pinhook. I did like he 2018 better than the 2021, but the new one is still very tasty.

Cracked the 6 Year War last night. Good flavors but a bit light for my palate. I'll continue to try these every year, but I think the high proof is definitely more my jam. Going to be on the hunt for some high proof store picks next.

[jledou]

Nice I ended up with a regular Bohemian and a High Proof Bohemian so a little different once I read the label a little closer but looking forward to seeing the difference side by side.

Just picked up a Blue Note barrel pick from the rick house collapse, initial couple of sips where the largest baking spice/ apple pie / caramel hit I have had from a bourbon. I will be grabbing a few more bottles at ~$40 a piece.

[stearns]

Finally killed off my first "real" bottle of bourbon last night, got it when somebody here told me to enter a pappy lottery 5 years ago, brought it home and cracked it as I was walking through the door, my old roommate and I poured some over ice and had a great time. I would have a pour every now and again over the years, then stopped drinking it and put it in the back of the cabinet. That's no way to live, and I'm tired of seeing an almost-empty bottle on the shelf. Peter and I killed it off, he poured a little Weller 12 to drink next to it, it's crazy to think that those are in any way related

[icehog3]

Great bottle kill, Ben!

Walked into a local smaller store I've been in before but didn't see anything interesting (at a reasonable price, anyway). I was opening the door to leave and he asked what I was looking for. Gave him my standard answer, "Booker's".

He produced a 2018 bottle from behind the counter. Imagine how surprised I was when I asked how much and he quoted me retail. Score! Based on what he had Blanton's, Weller 107 and some others priced at, I was shocked to say the least.

[CigarSquid]

Has anyone tried the Basil Hayden Toast?

I haven't had any of the Basil Hayden... thinking of snagging a bottle of the toast as well as the original to give them a try.

Any other recommendations for an entry level sipper? I do enjoy Angel's Envy, Eagle Rare, Bulleit.... I don't drink often but want to get more into it. Looking for smoother, since I am a rookie.

[icehog3]

Originally Posted by garryyjr

Has anyone tried the Basil Hayden Toast?

I haven't had any of the Basil Hayden... thinking of snagging a bottle of the toast as well as the original to give them a try.

Any other recommendations for an entry level sipper? I do enjoy Angel's Envy, Eagle Rare, Bulleit.... I don't drink often but want to get more into it. Looking for smoother, since I am a rookie.

Gary, while I love Beam, I'm not much for Basil Hayden. The regular bourbon is meh for my palate, and the Dark Rye is the worst bottle of whiskey I've ever purchased. Literally poured 90% down the drain.

Smooth entry level? First thought would be Elijah Craig. If available, EH Taylor BiB is another smooth solid choice. Neither as sweet as Angel's Envy or Eagle Rare, but those are both too syrupy sweet for my taste, try Elijah Craig and see if you like smooth with a bit less sweet.

You might also want to try some wheated bourbons, they can be sweet and smooth. Maker's 46, Welller Special Reserve, etc....

Discovering your jam is half the fun!

[CigarSquid]

Originally Posted by icehog3

Gary, while I love Beam, I'm not much for Basil Hayden. The regular bourbon is meh for my palate, and the Dark Rye is the worst bottle of whiskey I've ever purchased. Literally poured 90% down the drain.

Smooth entry level? First thought would be Elijah Craig. If available, EH Taylor BiB is another smooth solid choice. Neither as sweet as Angel's Envy or Eagle Rare, but those are both too syrupy sweet for my taste, try Elijah Craig and see if you like smooth with a bit less sweet.

You might also want to try some wheated bourbons, they can be sweet and smooth. Maker's 46, Welller Special Reserve, etc....

Discovering your jam is half the fun!

Elijah is around, I see lots of it, never tried it. Maker's... I know the normal is here, I am sure the 46 is too. Again, never tried Maker's anything...

Thanks for some ideas.

[stearns]

Once again I agree with Tom, haven't tried the toast but I probably won't, the regular was a very brief intro bourbon for me until I learned more about proof and more flavorful bourbons. I got the dark rye as a gift from the wife a couple years ago, I'm not sure what to do with it since I can't drain pour it, I've been thinking about making a cocktail that uses a splash of it but it would take a lot of cocktails to get through it.

If you want to stay on the Beam train, I can't recommend Knob Creek loud enough. The regular shelf bottle (should be $30ish), the 12 year (a little harder to find but it's around, probably $50) and store picks ($50-60, usually 9-10 years, higher proof at 120 vs 100 for the others) are all going to treat you really well. I love wheaters myself, if you can't find Weller Special Reserve give the Maker's a shot, 46 is really solid. Also regular Buffalo Trace, store picks can be really great but shelf bottles will get the job done too. It's an exciting time, take brief notes on likes and dislikes as you go and enjoy yourself!

[CigarSquid]

I had the 'regular' knob creek years ago, don't remember being a fan. I believe I have found Weller Special Reserve, I will check out the store on my way home.

Never had any Buffalo Trace as well, but seen and heard good things about it.

I think I am going to go to the liquor store, see what they have in the 50ml size and buy a few to try. They sell them cheaper than any bar will give me shots. Going to do my own whiskey sampling.

[jledou]

I will kick two more into the to try list if you can find them in a 50 ml try (great idea btw) Old Forester bottled in bond and Wild Turkey 101. Both are easy to find on the shelf and very reasonably priced.

[CigarSquid]

Originally Posted by jledou

I will kick two more into the to try list if you can find them in a 50 ml try (great idea btw) Old Forester bottled in bond and Wild Turkey 101. Both are easy to find on the shelf and very reasonably priced.

Never heard of the Old Forester before and wild turkey, I only have one memory of that and it isn't good... of course I was just out of high school then.

[stearns]

I'm going to add Evan Williams, Black Label or Bottled in Bond (I prefer Bottled in Bond but it is a little higher proof at 100). This is going to be in the same realm as Elijah Craig, same distillery (Heaven Hill). Old Forester is a good one, they have a few different distinct offerings. I love Wild Turkey 101, it's an interesting one because it's a cheap standard "get you drunk mixer" but also generally considered the best affordable bourbon by experts. There's so much to explore, 50mls are great for trying the stuff that comes in that size, bars help with the rest but also just buying a sh!t load of bottles will get the job done

[CigarSquid]

Originally Posted by stearns

I'm going to add Evan Williams, Black Label or Bottled in Bond (I prefer Bottled in Bond but it is a little higher proof at 100). This is going to be in the same realm as Elijah Craig, same distillery (Heaven Hill). Old Forester is a good one, they have a few different distinct offerings. I love Wild Turkey 101, it's an interesting one because it's a cheap standard "get you drunk mixer" but also generally considered the best affordable bourbon by experts. There's so much to explore, 50mls are great for trying the stuff that comes in that size, bars help with the rest but also just buying a sh!t load of bottles will get the job done

I grabbed a smaller bottle of Elijah Craig and Buffalo Trace. They didn't have much 50ml to test.

Buying a sh!t ton of bottles is a GREAT way to get through this but I don't have a sh!t ton of bottle fund currently.

[stearns]

Nice! Let us know your thoughts when you give them a try