Cigar Caddy 30 Count vs X-Treme 30 Count

kelmac07 · 07-09-2009, 03:44 PM

Fellow inmates...need some help with those that are using these products now. I purchased an X-Treme 30 count travel humidor from "cheaphumidors" and RECEIVED a Cigar Caddy 30 count. Of course I called and wanted an explanation on why I received a different item from what I ordered (hell, even my sales receipt shows that I ordered an X-Treme and not the Cigar Caddy). And of course they couldn't explain anything (but that is for a different posting).

The X-Treme comes with a humidifcation device that you add distilled water to every so often, whereas the Cigar Caddy uses Boveda with no humidification device. Of course the Boveda needs to be replaced every 2-3 months, whereas the other, just drop some distilled water in and roll. Is one better than the other? I also purchased a "tube" with the gel in it (add distilled water every now and again) to place in it. Will this help?

Which is better and maintaining the RH%, the Boveda or the humidification device? If you were to choose a travel humi, which would you prefer? Which works better from personal experience? I want to hear those comments. Thanks!!!!

colimo · 07-09-2009, 03:47 PM

i have the cigar caddy version and with the tube in it....it seems to work fine for me...you can always cut a hole in the top foam to add a similar humi device as in the extreme should you choose

AD720 · 07-09-2009, 03:49 PM

I'm pretty sure they are almost exactly the same except for the difference you mentioned and the branding.

AFA the humi goes I have a very small amount of beads in my 16 and 24 ct Pelicans but it is really only an issue on longer trips. For a day trip herf I don't even worry about it. When I went away for a week even with opening and closing it a lot, leaving it open for several mintues at a time it stayed pretty constant at 65%.

The beads are in modifed "credo" style pucks that I cut holes in the foam to fit. I can snap some pics when i get home if you want.

AD720 · 07-09-2009, 03:51 PM

I should add that I do like the style you have a lot. My pelicans are a little top heavy and tend to tip over but those don't seem to do that.

md4958 · 07-09-2009, 03:51 PM

I have both, and they are the same thing. I dont use humidification in mine anyway because they seal so well, but the floral foam wouldnt be my first choice.

kelmac07 · 07-09-2009, 04:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by md4958

I have both, and they are the same thing. I dont use humidification in mine anyway because they seal so well, but the floral foam wouldnt be my first choice.

Which foam do you prefer?

bigloo · 07-09-2009, 04:10 PM

I have the Cigar caddy 30 and use the Boveda... works great. I would not travel with the gel because is can still flow, a little mesh bag with beads would be better. As far as the actual boxes are concerned, all the same thing.

also, I think the bovedo solution is better here. Because of how airtight these are, the boveda will last more then the given 2 months, mine is at 6 months going strong (they go hard when they are done). I dont like to add moisture to these as they are airtight and humidity can rocket fast. The Boveda pack takes care of all this and again, if you leave the pack in that airtight box, it will outlast the reported shelf-life.

md4958 · 07-09-2009, 04:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by kelmac07

Which foam do you prefer?

by floral foam I was referring to the little humidification puck that came with the unit. Use the boveda packet, or get yourself a small bag of Shilala beads (he makes really small ones) Just PM Shilala (Scott)

Like I said however, unless youre going away for a very extended period, you probably dont need humidification. The things seal better than tupperware. Just keep the unit closed and locked when youre done pulling cigars out.

loki · 07-09-2009, 04:48 PM

the x-treme is made by xikar and the cigar caddy is made by otterbox as far as I know. I have 2 otters and a xikar, never had a problem with the otters, the xikar had a bad seal, I emailed them they sent me a new seal and I'm still not sure if it works properly or not. I'd personally go with the cigar caddy.

also I take the foam out and run beads. works like a charm

Bubba - NJ · 07-09-2009, 08:58 PM

I have a 30 ct. Cigar Caddy , a 10 ct Cigar Caddy and a 15 ct. Extreme case . Both small ones have the floral foam and work fine . The 30 ct has the Boveda pack in it since I bought a couple months ago and it is still in good shape but I almost never open it so that is a testament to how well it seals up . Looking at construction of the 3 cases , I would say the Cigar Caddies look a good bit more rugged with better and tighter fitting latches . Does the extreme 30 ct. case come with a vent releaselike the Cigar Caddy ?(little knob you un-screw to release pressure) Unless it's damaged I would keep the Cigar Caddy . Good luck with your quest for an answer from Cheap Humidors . Keep us posted on your resolution please .

kelmac07 · 07-09-2009, 11:17 PM

Thanks for all the great info guys...looks like I am gonna keep this. Here is the response I got this evening from cheaphumidors:

"Hi Michael

Thanks for writing. You are correct, this should be the Madeleine brand. We recently switched to the Cigar Caddy as they were holding up better and I apologize, it looks like we didn’t change the picture/description. I am happy to send a label for the free return of that item for a full refund if you wish."

At least they offered to pay for shipping.

JohnnyKay5 · 07-10-2009, 12:40 AM

time to get me one. My cigar caddy 15 count's seal busted on the way to Indy.

kelmac07 · 07-10-2009, 12:43 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by JohnnyKay5

time to get me one. My cigar caddy 15 count's seal busted on the way to Indy.

Was it from the air pressure of the flight? The 30 count has the air pressure valve.

JohnnyKay5 · 07-10-2009, 06:24 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by kelmac07

Was it from the air pressure of the flight? The 30 count has the air pressure valve.

you got it!

kelmac07 · 07-10-2009, 08:27 AM

Did your sticks survive?

JohnnyKay5 · 07-10-2009, 02:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by kelmac07

Did your sticks survive?

yup, no problem with them.. just a tightly sealed box when i arrived

07-10-2009, 02:41 PM

the 30 stick Cigar caddy and the 30 stick Xikar are the same exact case that is manufactured by S3 Case (Extreme). The difference is in the humidification. I prefer the Boveda in an airtight case.

kelmac07 · 07-11-2009, 10:06 AM

I have decided to keep the Cigar Caddy...thanks for all your assistance fellow BOTLs. Mods, you can lock this up.

07-09-2009, 03:44 PM	#1
kelmac07 Resident Maduro Whore!! Join Date: Apr 2009 First Name: Mac Location: Newport News, VA Posts: 27,322 Trading: (218)	Cigar Caddy 30 Count vs X-Treme 30 Count Fellow inmates...need some help with those that are using these products now. I purchased an X-Treme 30 count travel humidor from "cheaphumidors" and RECEIVED a Cigar Caddy 30 count. Of course I called and wanted an explanation on why I received a different item from what I ordered (hell, even my sales receipt shows that I ordered an X-Treme and not the Cigar Caddy). And of course they couldn't explain anything (but that is for a different posting). The X-Treme comes with a humidifcation device that you add distilled water to every so often, whereas the Cigar Caddy uses Boveda with no humidification device. Of course the Boveda needs to be replaced every 2-3 months, whereas the other, just drop some distilled water in and roll. Is one better than the other? I also purchased a "tube" with the gel in it (add distilled water every now and again) to place in it. Will this help? Which is better and maintaining the RH%, the Boveda or the humidification device? If you were to choose a travel humi, which would you prefer? Which works better from personal experience? I want to hear those comments. Thanks!!!!

07-09-2009, 03:47 PM	#2
colimo friend of Brother Maynard Join Date: Mar 2009 First Name: doug Location: centennial, colorado Posts: 1,322 Trading: (41)	Re: Cigar Caddy 30 Count vs X-Treme 30 Count i have the cigar caddy version and with the tube in it....it seems to work fine for me...you can always cut a hole in the top foam to add a similar humi device as in the extreme should you choose __________________ Life is too short for cheap beer, cheap liguor and bad cigars...gimme a guinness, glenlivet and a good cigar on a golf course and its heaven on earth!!

07-09-2009, 03:49 PM	#3
AD720 I'm nuts for the place Join Date: Oct 2008 First Name: Andrew Location: The City of BOTL-erly Love Posts: 2,684 Trading: (73)	Re: Cigar Caddy 30 Count vs X-Treme 30 Count I'm pretty sure they are almost exactly the same except for the difference you mentioned and the branding. AFA the humi goes I have a very small amount of beads in my 16 and 24 ct Pelicans but it is really only an issue on longer trips. For a day trip herf I don't even worry about it. When I went away for a week even with opening and closing it a lot, leaving it open for several mintues at a time it stayed pretty constant at 65%. The beads are in modifed "credo" style pucks that I cut holes in the foam to fit. I can snap some pics when i get home if you want. __________________

07-09-2009, 03:51 PM	#4
AD720 I'm nuts for the place Join Date: Oct 2008 First Name: Andrew Location: The City of BOTL-erly Love Posts: 2,684 Trading: (73)	Re: Cigar Caddy 30 Count vs X-Treme 30 Count I should add that I do like the style you have a lot. My pelicans are a little top heavy and tend to tip over but those don't seem to do that. __________________

07-09-2009, 03:51 PM	#5
md4958 Captain Cannoli Join Date: Oct 2008 First Name: Moe Location: Suffield, CT Posts: 5,712 Trading: (62)	Re: Cigar Caddy 30 Count vs X-Treme 30 Count I have both, and they are the same thing. I dont use humidification in mine anyway because they seal so well, but the floral foam wouldnt be my first choice. __________________ "One fart can foul the air for everyone" - Esteemed philosopher "If avoiding the nasty $hit is being a snob, them I am guilty as charged."- Same esteemed philosopher.

07-09-2009, 04:10 PM	#7
bigloo Crazy like a fox Join Date: Oct 2008 First Name: Lu Location: Rose City Posts: 905 Trading: (27)	Re: Cigar Caddy 30 Count vs X-Treme 30 Count I have the Cigar caddy 30 and use the Boveda... works great. I would not travel with the gel because is can still flow, a little mesh bag with beads would be better. As far as the actual boxes are concerned, all the same thing. also, I think the bovedo solution is better here. Because of how airtight these are, the boveda will last more then the given 2 months, mine is at 6 months going strong (they go hard when they are done). I dont like to add moisture to these as they are airtight and humidity can rocket fast. The Boveda pack takes care of all this and again, if you leave the pack in that airtight box, it will outlast the reported shelf-life.

07-09-2009, 04:48 PM	#9
loki H.A.T.E Join Date: Oct 2008 Location: Pittsburgh pa Posts: 1,484 Trading: (7)	Re: Cigar Caddy 30 Count vs X-Treme 30 Count the x-treme is made by xikar and the cigar caddy is made by otterbox as far as I know. I have 2 otters and a xikar, never had a problem with the otters, the xikar had a bad seal, I emailed them they sent me a new seal and I'm still not sure if it works properly or not. I'd personally go with the cigar caddy. also I take the foam out and run beads. works like a charm

07-09-2009, 08:58 PM	#10
Bubba - NJ Deep Cherry Finish Join Date: Oct 2008 First Name: Rolf Location: Tatooine Posts: 780 Trading: (4)	Re: Cigar Caddy 30 Count vs X-Treme 30 Count I have a 30 ct. Cigar Caddy , a 10 ct Cigar Caddy and a 15 ct. Extreme case . Both small ones have the floral foam and work fine . The 30 ct has the Boveda pack in it since I bought a couple months ago and it is still in good shape but I almost never open it so that is a testament to how well it seals up . Looking at construction of the 3 cases , I would say the Cigar Caddies look a good bit more rugged with better and tighter fitting latches . Does the extreme 30 ct. case come with a vent releaselike the Cigar Caddy ?(little knob you un-screw to release pressure) Unless it's damaged I would keep the Cigar Caddy . Good luck with your quest for an answer from Cheap Humidors . Keep us posted on your resolution please . __________________ Royale with cheese

07-09-2009, 11:17 PM	#11
kelmac07 Resident Maduro Whore!! Join Date: Apr 2009 First Name: Mac Location: Newport News, VA Posts: 27,322 Trading: (218)	Re: Cigar Caddy 30 Count vs X-Treme 30 Count Thanks for all the great info guys...looks like I am gonna keep this. Here is the response I got this evening from cheaphumidors: "Hi Michael Thanks for writing. You are correct, this should be the Madeleine brand. We recently switched to the Cigar Caddy as they were holding up better and I apologize, it looks like we didn’t change the picture/description. I am happy to send a label for the free return of that item for a full refund if you wish." At least they offered to pay for shipping.

07-10-2009, 12:40 AM	#12
JohnnyKay5 Armed Forces Tumbleweed Join Date: Oct 2008 Location: Chester, VA Posts: 1,046 Trading: (22)	Re: Cigar Caddy 30 Count vs X-Treme 30 Count time to get me one. My cigar caddy 15 count's seal busted on the way to Indy. __________________ *HIGH FIVE!*

07-10-2009, 08:27 AM	#15
kelmac07 Resident Maduro Whore!! Join Date: Apr 2009 First Name: Mac Location: Newport News, VA Posts: 27,322 Trading: (218)	Re: Cigar Caddy 30 Count vs X-Treme 30 Count Did your sticks survive?

07-10-2009, 02:41 PM	#17
RonC Guest Posts: n/a	Re: Cigar Caddy 30 Count vs X-Treme 30 Count the 30 stick Cigar caddy and the 30 stick Xikar are the same exact case that is manufactured by S3 Case (Extreme). The difference is in the humidification. I prefer the Boveda in an airtight case.

07-11-2009, 10:06 AM	#18
kelmac07 Resident Maduro Whore!! Join Date: Apr 2009 First Name: Mac Location: Newport News, VA Posts: 27,322 Trading: (218)	Re: Cigar Caddy 30 Count vs X-Treme 30 Count I have decided to keep the Cigar Caddy...thanks for all your assistance fellow BOTLs. Mods, you can lock this up.