Post your favorite cigar of ALL TIME.

[thechrisdotcom]

My fav is the Brickhouse Toro. I picked up a Toro Tin awhile ago, but they were only a one time thing. I prefer a robusto size cigar but Brickhouse's robusto is a bit big in the ring gauge size for me for a robusto. The toro's ring size is the same, though a bit longer in length for me, but no biggy. I get a better feel with the toro in my hand when the ring size is bigger. For the price and the amount of flavor that comes out of this cigar, make it my favorite cigar of all time. I haven't smoked many of them lately but when I don't know what to smoke, I grab a Brickhouse.

[Subvet642]

The best cigar I've ever smoked was a 2004 PSD #1 that a friend had gifted me.

[CigarSquid]

Originally Posted by thechrisdotcom

Haven't had one of these in a while. I do like them from what I remember. I may need to pick some up.

[Buckeye Jack]

80's Davidoff Dom Perignon on my 30th birthday......the thing smoked like a dream and I only hope I have another cigar that satisfies my pallate like that cigar did. Incidentally, it's the only Davi that I have ever smoked that I considered "on".

[fencefixer]

noob here so flavor profile fluctuates.. however so far the Berger & Argenti Entubar Quad Maduro is always a hit!

[Ervsuperb]

Originally Posted by fencefixer

noob here so flavor profile fluctuates.. however so far the Berger & Argenti Entubar Quad Maduro is always a hit!

This stick intrigues me. Think I'm going to pick up a 5pk and see what's up.


Relative noob, but I'd have to say;
LP Flying Pig #9
Dirty Rat and #9 Doble

Honorable mentions LG small batch #3 and Fuente Anejo 46

[FelonyRuckus]

Originally Posted by fencefixer

noob here so flavor profile fluctuates.. however so far the Berger & Argenti Entubar Quad Maduro is always a hit!

BTW I love these, I smoke a ton when I go to Vegas, it's the only place I've found them in a B&M

[Tredegar]

A few years ago I received an Opus X Perfeccion X in a blind taste test. It was the most memorable smoke I have ever had.

As long as I'm enjoying it, my favorite is whatever I happen to be smoking at that moment.

[BlindedByScience]

Several come to mind, but if I had to pick one and only one, it'd be the Padron 45th Anniversary in Maduro. Every one I've had the pleasure of smoking has been just....on.

[Islayphile]

Very close second to the 80th maduro

[pektel]

My favorites have been:

05 PLPC
04 Sig VI
05 CoLa
02 LGC MdO 3

Don't think I've ever had a bad one of those.

[DaBear]

Regular Production NCs:
Hemingway Maduros(save for the WOAM, never really did much for me)
PAM 64
LP No. 9

More limited stuff/CCs:
Tat Face
08 HdM Epicure No. 2
Viaje S&B ?
Oliva O blue cloth band(seriously probably the best stick I have ever had )

[irratebass]

Originally Posted by DaBear

Oliva O blue cloth band(seriously probably the best stick I have ever had )

I forgot the Oliva Blue Cloth....that WAS a good smoke.

[DaBear]

Originally Posted by DaBear

Regular Production NCs:
Hemingway Maduros(save for the WOAM, never really did much for me)
PAM 64
LP No. 9

More limited stuff/CCs:
Tat Face
08 HdM Epicure No. 2
Viaje S&B ?
Oliva O blue cloth band(seriously probably the best stick I have ever had )

And now to add to the latter list: 07 PLPC

[dvickery]

bolivar corona...rated it a 100 point cigar 10 years ago and havnt smoked any cigars that come close since.

second place on my all time list goes to a few davidoff 1000's i had in london a couple of years ago.

derrek

Bolivar Corona Extra (which has tragically been discontinued)
Montecristo No. 2
Padron 1926 No. 9 Natural

[awsmith4]

Hard to say what was the best or my favorite especially if I am including ones I have sampled in PPPs. However a couple stand out


Almost every cigar from this bomb in '07 (thanks Twillis) but especially the '83 ERdM PL




40s Cabana thanks to Balls



And an 02 RA 898, though I think this one was less to do with the cigar and more with the location and the company.



Many more spring to mind though they are almost all tied to a good herfing experience so I often wonder how good they were or was I just in that good a mood.

[Doctorossi]

Originally Posted by awsmith4

Man... why did they have to stop making those?

[awsmith4]

Originally Posted by Doctorossi

Man... why did they have to stop making those?

I agree a great cigar, but at least the Sunsets at Shack will be around