What's most important when rating a cigar?

I think in terms of flavor, apperence, value, construction and then overall experience which is just some **** I made up lol. The ones that matter the most, if I had rto rank them are Flavor, Construction and Value.

[issues]

Originally Posted by Addiction

The ones that matter the most, if I had to rank them are Flavor, Construction and Value.

I would agree with that exact order.

Although if a cigar is too expensive, the chance of me ever trying it is minimal...

So I would probably break it down to 60%F/25%C/15%V.