Cigar to introduce a person?

[T.G]

Off the top of my head:

For a mild cigar I'd say
Butera Royal Vintage Capo Grande churchill w/ the natural wrapper if you can find them,
Playboy by Don Diego (this one has a white/biege/pink/gold trim band that says "Playboy by Don Diego" on the band, not to be confused with the new Playboy with the black/silver band which tastes like lawn clippings)
Nat Sherman "Host" line
Griffins
and a second vote for Bob's Macanudo Hyde Park suggestion.

If you want to move it up a notch to medium or so to keep up with the IPA:
Drew Estates Chateau Real Maduro,
HdM Excalibur / Excalibur 1066
Graycliff Red (original)
AVO XO