Best small cigar under $2

[Tio Gato]

Originally Posted by borndead1

Muniemakers!

You can't go wrong with a Muniemaker, all tobacco and yummy.
If you like a mild yet flavorful morning smoke, the 5 Vegas Nugget is a nice choice. Can be had reasonably on the Devil Site. Another mild one is the Fonseca 2-2, it's about the right size for your walk.
You may want to check Mike's Cigars for the Old Fashioned bundles. Seconds of Mac.s and Partagas. Good value there so you don't feel bad if you don't nub it.