Don Pepin Garcia Series JJ Maduro Selecto

Ratters · 12-29-2008, 07:14 PM

Cigar: Don Pepin Garcia Series JJ Maduro Selecto
Wrapper: Nicaraguan Maduro
Binder: Nicaragua
Filler: Nicaraguan Corojo and Criollo
Vitola: 5x50
Price: Free, gifted by elderboy02 thank you very much. 7.80 a stick of CI.

Setting: Sun room, 5 pm, about 50 degrees out and dropping. Drinking a Snapple soon to be replaced by a root beer.

Pre-light: The cigar has a nice light chocolate brown appearance, with a nice oily sheen. The wrapper appeared lighter to me than what I remember for seeing them in the shops. The veins are medium to heavy and the wrap lines are clearly visible, but the cigar is solid with little to no soft spots. The cap is nicely rounded and cut easily using the Cranial Screw Top method. The wrapper has a nice light barnyard scent to it with a touch of spice, and the cold draw is of sweet tobacco.

First third: After completely lighting the foot I was greeted with large amounts of smoke on the first puff. The cigar has that definite Pepin bite to it, but also some sweetness. Initial flavors were of bitter coffee and roasted nuts, with a woody undertone. The burn line is a tad wavy but we'll see where it goes. The draw on the cigar is nigh perfect and the ash seems to be holding firm. As I get about an inch in the pepper is starting to irritate the back of the throat.

Second third: The irritation has lessoned which is nice. What remains is that woody/cedar undertone with the nutty taste and coffee bitterness. All in all it makes for a pleasant smoke. Once I started on the root beer some of the flavors in the cigar really started to open up, the sweetness playing off the spice. Burn continues a bit wavy but nothing that requires attention. Burn rate seems somewhat quick for something so fully packed with tobacco, hitting the second third right at about the 20 minute mark. Draw and smoke production still please and the finish is smooth with a tad of bitter on the tongue, like from a good cup o joe. Body is in the medium to full range, but not feeling much strength to the smoke yet.

Final third: At the very end of the the second third the spice really mellowed out. The flavors remain though the nuttiness has really gone to the background and the cedar flavor has come to the fore. It is becoming a very pleasant smoke. The bitterness remains but it adds more than detracts from the cigar. The ash is holding strong if a bit flakey. The smoke is really thick and creamy making for great smoke rings. As I get to the end this sweet chocolately flavor started coming out. Really finishing on a high note.

Final thoughts: I want to thank Daniel for giving me the opportunity to smoke and review this cigar. It started off a bit rough but really came into it's own about the half way point. As far as Pepins are concerned I think I still prefer the Cuban Classic, but this is a close second.

Liked it: Yes
Buy again: Didn't buy this one, but when I can buy smokes again I'll definitely be keeping my eye on Joe Cigar for a deal.
Reccommend: Definitely

12-29-2008, 07:14 PM	#1
Ratters Have My Own Room Join Date: Oct 2008 Posts: 1,848 Trading: (2)	Don Pepin Garcia Series JJ Maduro Selecto Cigar: Don Pepin Garcia Series JJ Maduro Selecto Wrapper: Nicaraguan Maduro Binder: Nicaragua Filler: Nicaraguan Corojo and Criollo Vitola: 5x50 Price: Free, gifted by elderboy02 thank you very much. 7.80 a stick of CI. Setting: Sun room, 5 pm, about 50 degrees out and dropping. Drinking a Snapple soon to be replaced by a root beer. Pre-light: The cigar has a nice light chocolate brown appearance, with a nice oily sheen. The wrapper appeared lighter to me than what I remember for seeing them in the shops. The veins are medium to heavy and the wrap lines are clearly visible, but the cigar is solid with little to no soft spots. The cap is nicely rounded and cut easily using the Cranial Screw Top method. The wrapper has a nice light barnyard scent to it with a touch of spice, and the cold draw is of sweet tobacco. First third: After completely lighting the foot I was greeted with large amounts of smoke on the first puff. The cigar has that definite Pepin bite to it, but also some sweetness. Initial flavors were of bitter coffee and roasted nuts, with a woody undertone. The burn line is a tad wavy but we'll see where it goes. The draw on the cigar is nigh perfect and the ash seems to be holding firm. As I get about an inch in the pepper is starting to irritate the back of the throat. Second third: The irritation has lessoned which is nice. What remains is that woody/cedar undertone with the nutty taste and coffee bitterness. All in all it makes for a pleasant smoke. Once I started on the root beer some of the flavors in the cigar really started to open up, the sweetness playing off the spice. Burn continues a bit wavy but nothing that requires attention. Burn rate seems somewhat quick for something so fully packed with tobacco, hitting the second third right at about the 20 minute mark. Draw and smoke production still please and the finish is smooth with a tad of bitter on the tongue, like from a good cup o joe. Body is in the medium to full range, but not feeling much strength to the smoke yet. Final third: At the very end of the the second third the spice really mellowed out. The flavors remain though the nuttiness has really gone to the background and the cedar flavor has come to the fore. It is becoming a very pleasant smoke. The bitterness remains but it adds more than detracts from the cigar. The ash is holding strong if a bit flakey. The smoke is really thick and creamy making for great smoke rings. As I get to the end this sweet chocolately flavor started coming out. Really finishing on a high note. Final thoughts: I want to thank Daniel for giving me the opportunity to smoke and review this cigar. It started off a bit rough but really came into it's own about the half way point. As far as Pepins are concerned I think I still prefer the Cuban Classic, but this is a close second. Liked it: Yes Buy again: Didn't buy this one, but when I can buy smokes again I'll definitely be keeping my eye on Joe Cigar for a deal. Reccommend: Definitely