I just found this blog post about Pumpkin Ales. Thought it might be interesting to read another opinion about a few of the beers mentioned in this thread:
That's a good read. I think their notes are spot on also. Reading the note about Pumking reminded me, the prominent flavor was definitely gingerbread, and I definitely enjoyed that. In fact, I enjoyed all 22 oz in a single sitting by myself, so no need to heed DCB's advice on sharing it with 6 people, that's just foolish!