Help me decide which pipe to buy!

Hey guys,

Being of relatively modest means, I am only able to buy one pipe to add to my collection at the moment. I need your help deciding.

Budget is capped at ~70 dollars. I have narrowed it down to the following choices. You are welcome to suggest other brands (Boswell, Stanwell, etc.) but I am specifically wanting a pipe by these makers and like these pipes. Help me pick between them. Click the picture for the link to the for sale page at various pipe dealers.

My main collection right now consists of a Bjarne Bent Brandy, a couple of straight Dr. Grabows and Kaywoodies, and a Savinelli Hercules 611EX (I think its a dublin shape iirc) coming from fleabay.

Thanks for looking.

- Tyler

Johs Bent Apple - $68 from smokingpipes.com


Savinelli Hercules 316EX - $70 from cupojoes.com


Brebbia Rocciata Black Sandblast -$68 from pipesandcigars.com


Jirsa Rustic Dublin - $68 from pipesandcigars.com


I plan to order some baccy as well, so I would like to order from either pipesandcigars.com, cupojoes, or smokingpipes.