Pumpkin Ales

MikeyC · 10-26-2009, 09:52 PM

One of the things I like best about fall is drinking some yummy Pumpkin Ales! It's the only thing that makes putting up with all the annoying "leaf peepers" remotely bearable.

I've tried a number of Pumpkin Ales this year some new and some old favorites. I thought I'd share my thoughts on the ones I've tried and would love to hear others thoughts on the Pumpkin Ales they've tried.

Shipyard Pumpkin - after last year's pumpkin ale taste test this was my favorite. Definitely on the sweet side and pumpkin pie spice flavors are pretty prominent.

Dogfish Head Punkin' Ale - DH puts out so many delicious beers and their Punkin' Ale is no exception. Pumpkin pie spices are there but not overpowering. There's also a nice maltiness to this beer and the 7% ABV is a nice bonus. The flavor profile of this beer is tipped toward sweetness but not overwhelmingly which makes it very drinkable.

Blue Moon Pumpkin Ale - this is a pumpkin ale I would expect out of a company run by Molsen/Coors. This beer completely lacked pumpkin pie spice or even pumpkin flavor. If you took the label off the bottle I would have had no idea that this was supposed to be a pumpkin ale. This beer generally lacked flavor and was seriously boring!! As a side note I recently tried some Blue Moon Peanutbutter beer and that was . . . well interesting. At least you could taste the peanuts.

Smuttynose Pumpkin Ale - this beer was my personal favorite of the four. The flavor profile of this beer was much closer to being "balanced" (not too sweet and not too bitter). You could DEFINITELY taste pumpkin in this beer and the pumpkin pie spices were much more subtle. It was very drinkable especially for a pumpkin ale. This beer was also overwhelmingly prefered by my friends who also tried the other beers.

I'm hoping to get my hands on some Weyerbacher Pumpkin Ale before fall is over as I hear good things about it.

So what's your favorite Pumpkin Ale and why?

Mark C · 10-27-2009, 07:22 AM

I wait all year for October to come around, and the pumpkin beer to start flowing.

My favorites:

(1) Southern Tier Pumking - First time I've had this one. In 6 years of trying every pumpkin ale I could find, this is the first time I've found a beer to overthrow the reigning champ (Post Road). Damn shame it's so hard to find. Smooth, creamy, sweet and spicy. I generally hate sweet beer, but this was perfection in a glass for me. 10% ABV if I remember right.
(2) Post Road Pumpkin Ale - First pumpkin ale I ever had, and until Pumking came along, it was my favorite. It's become much easier to find in the last 5 or 6 yrs, and that's a good thing. Strong on the spices, and not sweet, exactly what I'm looking for.
(2) Buffalo bill Pumpkin Ale - Very similar to Post Road. Haven't had them side-by-side, but they're close enough I can't choose a favorite between the two. Couldn't find this one this year.
(4) Weyerbacher Imperial Pumpkin Ale - Something a little different. Little more body to this beer, still prominent on the spices though, also not the easiest one to find.

I agree with your tasting notes for the beers you listed. I generally prefer stronger pumpkin pie spice flavors in my pumpkin beer, the ones you mentioned are a little too subtle for me (except the Shipyard, as you noted).

For a surprise, try Budweiser's Jack. I wasn't expecting much, but was pleasantly surprised. Not a top ranking pumpkin beer, but very nice considering the source. I like it more than Blue Moon Pumpkin.

BeerAdvocate · 10-27-2009, 08:41 AM

Ofallon and Schlafly are my two favorite. Both from Missouri!

yourchoice · 10-27-2009, 09:37 AM

Weyerbacher Pumpkin Ale is my favorite. I prefer it much more than the Dogfish Head. I need to try some more varieties though.

Poronico · 10-27-2009, 09:42 AM

One of my favorite Pumpkin Ales is the Elysian Night Owl Pumpkin Ale, 150lbs of pumpkin per batch along with the traditional spices. Its pretty epic imo

MikeyC · 10-27-2009, 10:02 AM

I just found this blog post about Pumpkin Ales. Thought it might be interesting to read another opinion about a few of the beers mentioned in this thread:

http://drinkcraftbeer.com/editorial/...-tasteoff.html

Quote:

Originally Posted by Poronico

One of my favorite Pumpkin Ales is the Elysian Night Owl Pumpkin Ale, 150lbs of pumpkin per batch along with the traditional spices. Its pretty epic imo

That sounds like a lot of pumpkin although I don't know how big the batches are. I've seen quite a range of fermenting tanks in my day. The Sam Adams Brewery in Boston has tanks about 68 barrels in size and the Coors brewery in Golden, CO has fermenting tanks over 1400 barrels in size.

Also, it looks like Elysian is in WA so I'm not sure I'd ever see that beer out here on the other coast.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mark C

I agree with your tasting notes for the beers you listed. I generally prefer stronger pumpkin pie spice flavors in my pumpkin beer, the ones you mentioned are a little too subtle for me (except the Shipyard, as you noted).

I enjoy the Pumpkin Ales where you can taste the pumpkin pie spices but sometimes brewers do go over the top with it. The Shipyard IMO is a nice level of spice. I would say though overall I prefer a more subtle pumpkin pie spice flavor with a stronger note of actual pumpkin which is why the Smuttynose is at the top of my list. It's not overly sweet either which is another place brewers can go wrong with this style IMO.

Poronico · 10-27-2009, 10:04 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MikeyC

I just found this blog post about Pumpkin Ales. Thought it might be interesting to read another opinion about a few of the beers mentioned in this thread:

http://drinkcraftbeer.com/editorial/...-tasteoff.html

That sounds like a lot of pumpkin although I don't know how big the batches are. I've seen quite a range of fermenting tanks in my day. The Sam Adams Brewery in Boston has tanks about 68 barrels in size and the Coors brewery in Golden, CO has fermenting tanks over 1400 barrels in size.

Also, it looks like Elysian is in WA so I'm not sure I'd ever see that beer out here on the other coast.

From what I understand it works out to about 7lbs per barrel. One of the local shops has it here, its quite good.

MikeyC · 10-27-2009, 10:08 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Poronico

From what I understand it works out to about 7lbs per barrel. One of the local shops has it here, its quite good.

That's a good amount of pumpkin. I'll have to keep my eyes peeled to see if it made it out to this coast.

vankleekkw · 10-27-2009, 11:22 AM

Southern Tier is sooo good. I love it when you finish the sip and start tasting the crust.

Mark C · 10-27-2009, 11:24 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MikeyC

I just found this blog post about Pumpkin Ales. Thought it might be interesting to read another opinion about a few of the beers mentioned in this thread:

http://drinkcraftbeer.com/editorial/...-tasteoff.html

That's a good read. I think their notes are spot on also. Reading the note about Pumking reminded me, the prominent flavor was definitely gingerbread, and I definitely enjoyed that. In fact, I enjoyed all 22 oz in a single sitting by myself, so no need to heed DCB's advice on sharing it with 6 people, that's just foolish!

cherrybomb · 10-27-2009, 10:18 PM

dogfish

10-28-2009, 08:54 PM

Dogfish and Weyerbacher....it's a nice change of pace beer but sometimes it can get cloyingly sweet.

BigFrank · 10-29-2009, 05:09 PM

Ive had Dogfish, Weyerbacher, and Post Road this year. Personally weyerbacher was a little too winey for me this year. dogfish didnt disappoint and the Post Road, which I think is brewed by Brooklyn brewery under a different name was good also.

jwfish81 · 10-29-2009, 05:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by BeerAdvocate

Ofallon and Schlafly are my two favorite. Both from Missouri!

You can't go wrong with anything Schlafly for that matter!

10-29-2009, 06:37 PM

Cottonwood Pumpkin Ale, brewed in Mooresville, NC by Carolina Beer Company

BlackDog · 10-31-2009, 02:25 PM

Picked up 2 bombers of Pumking by Southern Tier Brewery. Was suprised to find it in the local shop, so I grabbed 2. Will drink it while watching the baseball game. Also got a bomber of Fullers ESB and a bottle of Chimay Blue.

Mark C · 11-01-2009, 07:11 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by BlackDog

Picked up 2 bombers of Pumking by Southern Tier Brewery. Was suprised to find it in the local shop, so I grabbed 2. Will drink it while watching the baseball game. Also got a bomber of Fullers ESB and a bottle of Chimay Blue.

I'm jealous, I've been striking out everywhere I go for the last month. Same story everywhere 'we only got two cases, sold out the first day'. Enjoy 'em!

BigFrank · 11-01-2009, 06:13 PM

Spot near me has southern tier. I dont know if they have the pumking but I know they have their winter brew in.

IBQTEE1 · 11-02-2009, 01:23 PM

I had the Dogfish Punkin Ale on Saturday for the 1st time and I really enjoyed it. Need to go out and get some more. Loved the spice to it.

fissure · 11-02-2009, 01:44 PM

Had the PumKing on saturday. It was really good, but at $8 something for a bomber, I won't be drinking too many.

10-26-2009, 09:52 PM	#1
MikeyC member of the CA MINYAN Join Date: Oct 2008 Location: Somewhere out there Posts: 1,782 Trading: (11)	Pumpkin Ales One of the things I like best about fall is drinking some yummy Pumpkin Ales! It's the only thing that makes putting up with all the annoying "leaf peepers" remotely bearable. I've tried a number of Pumpkin Ales this year some new and some old favorites. I thought I'd share my thoughts on the ones I've tried and would love to hear others thoughts on the Pumpkin Ales they've tried. Shipyard Pumpkin - after last year's pumpkin ale taste test this was my favorite. Definitely on the sweet side and pumpkin pie spice flavors are pretty prominent. Dogfish Head Punkin' Ale - DH puts out so many delicious beers and their Punkin' Ale is no exception. Pumpkin pie spices are there but not overpowering. There's also a nice maltiness to this beer and the 7% ABV is a nice bonus. The flavor profile of this beer is tipped toward sweetness but not overwhelmingly which makes it very drinkable. Blue Moon Pumpkin Ale - this is a pumpkin ale I would expect out of a company run by Molsen/Coors. This beer completely lacked pumpkin pie spice or even pumpkin flavor. If you took the label off the bottle I would have had no idea that this was supposed to be a pumpkin ale. This beer generally lacked flavor and was seriously boring!! As a side note I recently tried some Blue Moon Peanutbutter beer and that was . . . well interesting. At least you could taste the peanuts. Smuttynose Pumpkin Ale - this beer was my personal favorite of the four. The flavor profile of this beer was much closer to being "balanced" (not too sweet and not too bitter). You could DEFINITELY taste pumpkin in this beer and the pumpkin pie spices were much more subtle. It was very drinkable especially for a pumpkin ale. This beer was also overwhelmingly prefered by my friends who also tried the other beers. I'm hoping to get my hands on some Weyerbacher Pumpkin Ale before fall is over as I hear good things about it. So what's your favorite Pumpkin Ale and why? __________________ I think Pandora's box was actually a humidor!

10-27-2009, 07:22 AM	#2
Mark C Feeling at Home Join Date: Oct 2008 Location: SE PA Posts: 674 Trading: (4)	Re: Pumpkin Ales I wait all year for October to come around, and the pumpkin beer to start flowing. My favorites: (1) Southern Tier Pumking - First time I've had this one. In 6 years of trying every pumpkin ale I could find, this is the first time I've found a beer to overthrow the reigning champ (Post Road). Damn shame it's so hard to find. Smooth, creamy, sweet and spicy. I generally hate sweet beer, but this was perfection in a glass for me. 10% ABV if I remember right. (2) Post Road Pumpkin Ale - First pumpkin ale I ever had, and until Pumking came along, it was my favorite. It's become much easier to find in the last 5 or 6 yrs, and that's a good thing. Strong on the spices, and not sweet, exactly what I'm looking for. (2) Buffalo bill Pumpkin Ale - Very similar to Post Road. Haven't had them side-by-side, but they're close enough I can't choose a favorite between the two. Couldn't find this one this year. (4) Weyerbacher Imperial Pumpkin Ale - Something a little different. Little more body to this beer, still prominent on the spices though, also not the easiest one to find. I agree with your tasting notes for the beers you listed. I generally prefer stronger pumpkin pie spice flavors in my pumpkin beer, the ones you mentioned are a little too subtle for me (except the Shipyard, as you noted). For a surprise, try Budweiser's Jack. I wasn't expecting much, but was pleasantly surprised. Not a top ranking pumpkin beer, but very nice considering the source. I like it more than Blue Moon Pumpkin.

10-27-2009, 08:41 AM	#3
BeerAdvocate BeerHunter Join Date: Mar 2009 First Name: Travis Location: Topeka, KS Posts: 1,912 Trading: (45)	Re: Pumpkin Ales Ofallon and Schlafly are my two favorite. Both from Missouri! __________________ *I Brew the Beer I Drink*

10-27-2009, 09:37 AM	#4
yourchoice Down the stretch Join Date: Oct 2008 First Name: Joel Location: South Jersey Posts: 4,091 Trading: (36)	Re: Pumpkin Ales Weyerbacher Pumpkin Ale is my favorite. I prefer it much more than the Dogfish Head. I need to try some more varieties though.

10-27-2009, 09:42 AM	#5
Poronico Teh Forever Noob Join Date: Aug 2009 First Name: Jesse Location: Bonney Lake, Wa Posts: 868 Trading: (5)	Re: Pumpkin Ales One of my favorite Pumpkin Ales is the Elysian Night Owl Pumpkin Ale, 150lbs of pumpkin per batch along with the traditional spices. Its pretty epic imo __________________ Fellows, leave the tight pants to the ladies. If I can count the coins in your pocket, you better use them to call the tailor. "TMIMITW"

10-27-2009, 11:22 AM	#9
vankleekkw Still Watching My Back Join Date: Nov 2008 First Name: Kris Location: Round Lake, IL Posts: 136 Trading: (3)	Re: Pumpkin Ales Southern Tier is sooo good. I love it when you finish the sip and start tasting the crust.

10-27-2009, 10:18 PM	#11
cherrybomb Adjusting to the Life Join Date: Oct 2008 First Name: Chris Location: somewhere over the rainbow Posts: 291 Trading: (15)	Re: Pumpkin Ales dogfish __________________ It is better to be hated for who you are, then loved for what you are not

10-28-2009, 08:54 PM	#12
avid toker Guest Posts: n/a	Re: Pumpkin Ales Dogfish and Weyerbacher....it's a nice change of pace beer but sometimes it can get cloyingly sweet.

10-29-2009, 05:09 PM	#13
BigFrank 5 3 1 Join Date: Nov 2008 First Name: Frank Location: Gym or Sofa. Posts: 1,896 Trading: (25)	Re: Pumpkin Ales Ive had Dogfish, Weyerbacher, and Post Road this year. Personally weyerbacher was a little too winey for me this year. dogfish didnt disappoint and the Post Road, which I think is brewed by Brooklyn brewery under a different name was good also. __________________ " Hope is the first step on the road to disappointment. "

10-29-2009, 06:37 PM	#15
e36bt Guest Posts: n/a	Re: Pumpkin Ales Cottonwood Pumpkin Ale, brewed in Mooresville, NC by Carolina Beer Company

10-31-2009, 02:25 PM	#16
BlackDog Gonna make you groove... Join Date: Oct 2008 First Name: Warren Location: Minneapolis, MN Posts: 2,468 Trading: (19)	Re: Pumpkin Ales Picked up 2 bombers of Pumking by Southern Tier Brewery. Was suprised to find it in the local shop, so I grabbed 2. Will drink it while watching the baseball game. Also got a bomber of Fullers ESB and a bottle of Chimay Blue. __________________ "We live in the good of this."

11-01-2009, 06:13 PM	#18
BigFrank 5 3 1 Join Date: Nov 2008 First Name: Frank Location: Gym or Sofa. Posts: 1,896 Trading: (25)	Re: Pumpkin Ales Spot near me has southern tier. I dont know if they have the pumking but I know they have their winter brew in. __________________ " Hope is the first step on the road to disappointment. "

11-02-2009, 01:23 PM	#19
IBQTEE1 Crazy K Join Date: Oct 2008 First Name: Kristin Location: Here and there Posts: 2,563 Trading: (6)	Re: Pumpkin Ales I had the Dogfish Punkin Ale on Saturday for the 1st time and I really enjoyed it. Need to go out and get some more. Loved the spice to it. __________________ It's a Good Day to Smoke a Cigar!!!

11-02-2009, 01:44 PM	#20
fissure DHC Black Ops Join Date: Oct 2008 First Name: Steve Location: Grand Blanc, Mi Posts: 1,184 Trading: (48)	Re: Pumpkin Ales Had the PumKing on saturday. It was really good, but at $8 something for a bomber, I won't be drinking too many.