What is your favorite Scotch Whisky

[Heatmiser]

Originally Posted by DAFU

Highland Park for me.

x2!!! Their 18 year old scotch is my favorite!!!

[Eleven]

Being even newer to SMS's than Cigars, I have come to like Aberlour and Glenmorangie, both 10 year old if I am not mistaken. (nope, Aberlour is 12, just checked)

The Aberlour was very nice served up neat, but I found the Glenmorangie needed a little water to help it along (or me I should say!) and at this moment I am drinking some Glenmorangie on the rocks, and its not bad.

I am also enjoying a decent hand rolled corona from Stogies Smoke Shop in St. Augustine that I picked a few weeks ago. Not bad for a no-name stick.

[s0leful0ne]

I've decided to dabble into this scotch business. Is there any that you guys recommend I start tasting?

[Scottw]

Originally Posted by Heatmiser

x2!!! Their 18 year old scotch is my favorite!!!

I had the 40 yr at a tasting, it was crazy good.

Soleful, what do you want to spend on the learning process and have you had single malts before? If so, what kinds and what did you think of the flavor profiles? If you never had a single malt, I would reccommend a "lowland" region whisky . It will be a flavor profile of sweet butterscotch with a smooth finish. You may try Glenkinchie, Auchentoshan or my pick for the brand new scotchdrinker, McClelland Lowland, it's about $22 per bottle. The others start in the $40's.

[s0leful0ne]

i guess i'd start with a bottle under 40 then if i enjoy it, I could pick up the next bottle a little pricier

Originally Posted by s0leful0ne

I've decided to dabble into this scotch business. Is there any that you guys recommend I start tasting?

old pulteny, it's not too pricy and pretty tasty

Anybody try Lismore Single Malt? I picked up a bottle for $28.00 Saturday. A nice fruity nose, bit of a short finish, but otherwise not too shabby.

[s0leful0ne]

Picked up a bottle of McClelland's Highland the guy in the shop talked me into, it was one of the cheaper ones, and one of the only ones suggested in stock. I'll give it a whirl tonight after the gym.

Originally Posted by SmokeyNL

old pulteny, it's not too pricy and pretty tasty

Seconded, after following Simon's recommendation!

Dear All Members ,

Here are some of the Manufactures of Excellent Scotch Whiskeys:

American Single Malt Whiskeys

* Charbay
* McCarthy's
* Notch
* Peregrine Rock
* St. George
* Stranahan's
* Wasmund's
* Woodstone Creek

American Corn Whiskeys


* Catdaddy
* Mountain Moonshine
* Old Gristmill
* Old Oak
* Virginia Lightning
* Georgia Moon
* Dixie Dew
* Mellow Corn
* J.W. Corn
* Platte Valley


Bourbon whiskey

The following distilleries are open to the public.

* Four Roses Distillery — Lawrenceburg, Kentucky
* Heaven Hill Distillery, Bardstown, Kentucky
* Buffalo Trace Distillery — Frankfort, Kentucky
* Jim Beam Distilleries, Clermont, Kentucky
* Woodford Reserve Distillery — Versailles, Kentucky
* Tom Moore - Bardstown, Kentucky
* Maker's Mark Distillery — Loretto, Kentucky
* Wild Turkey Distillery — Lawrenceburg, Kentucky

Kentucky Bourbons

* 1792 — Barton Distillery, Bardstown, Kentucky
* Ancient Age — Buffalo Trace Distillery, Frankfort, Kentucky
* Baker's — Jim Beam Distilleries, Clermont, Kentucky & Boston, Kentucky
* Barclay's - Barton Distillery, Bardstown, Kentucky
* Basil Hayden's — Jim Beam Distilleries, Clermont & Boston, Kentucky
* Benchmark & Benchmark XO (single-barrel) -Buffalo Trace Distillery, Frankfort, Kentucky
* Black Maple Hill - Bardstown, Kentucky
* Blanton's — Buffalo Trace Distillery — Frankfort, Kentucky
* Booker's — Jim Beam Distilleries, Clermont & Boston, Kentucky
* Buffalo Trace — Franklin County, Kentucky
* Bulleit Bourbon — Lawrenceburg, Kentucky
* Cabin Still - Heaven Hill Distillery, Bardstown, Kentucky
* Colonel Lee - Barton Distillery, Bardstown, Kentucky
* Corner Creek — Bardstown, Kentucky
* Daniel Stewart - Heaven Hill Distillery, Bardstown, Kentucky
* Eagle Rare — Buffalo Trace Distillery, Frankfort, Kentucky
* Early Times — Brown-Forman, Louisville, Kentucky (export version)
* Echo Springs - Heaven Hill Distillery, Bardstown, Kentucky
* Elijah Craig & Elijah Craig Single-Barrel — Heaven Hill Distillery, Bardstown, Kentucky
* Elmer T. Lee — Buffalo Trace Distillery, Frankfort, Kentucky
* Evan Williams — Heaven Hill Distillery, Bardstown, Kentucky
* Ezra Brooks Old Ezra Rare Old Sippin' Whiskey — Heaven Hill Distillery, Bardstown, Kentucky
* Fighting **** — Kentucky Bourbon Distillers, Bardstown, Kentucky
* Four Roses — Four Roses Distillery, Lawrenceburg, Kentucky
* George T. Stagg— Franklin County, Kentucky
* Hancock's Reserve - Buffalo Trace Distillery, Frankfort, Kentucky
* Heaven Hill — Heaven Hill Distillery, Bardstown, Kentucky
* Henry Clay Rare - Henry Clay Distillery, Kentucky (out of production)
* Henry McKenna - Heaven Hill Distillery, Bardstown, Kentucky
* I. W. Harper - Bernheim Distillery, Louisville, Kentucky
* Jacob's Well - Jim Beam Distilleries, Clermont & Boston, Kentucky
* James E. Pepper - Berheim Distillery, Louisville, Kentucky
* Jim Beam — Jim Beam Distilleries, Clermont & Boston, Kentucky
* J.T.S. Brown - Heaven Hill Distillery, Bardstown, Kentucky
* J. W. Dant - Heaven Hill Distillery, Bardstown, Kentucky
* Kentucky Gentleman — Barton Distillery, Bardstown, Kentucky
* Kentucky Tavern - Barton Distillery, Bardstown, Kentucky
* Kentucky Vintage - Bardstown, Kentucky
* Knob Creek— Jim Beam Distilleries, Clermont & Boston, Kentucky
* Maker's Mark — Maker's Mark Distillery, Loretto, Kentucky
* Mark Twain - Mark Twain Distilling Co. Bardstown, Kentucky
* Mattingly & Moore - Heaven Hill Distillery, Bardstown, Kentucky
* Noah's Mill - Kentucky Bourbon Distillers, Bardstown, Kentucky
* Old Bardstown - Kentucky Bourbon Distillers, Bardstown, Kentucky
* Old Charter— Buffalo Trace Distillery, Frankfort, Kentucky
* Old Crow — Jim Beam Distilleries, Clermont & Boston, Kentucky
* Old Fitzgerald - Heaven Hill Distillery, Bardstown, Kentucky
* Old Forester — Brown-Forman, Louisville, Kentucky
* Old Grand-Dad — Jim Beam Distilleries, Clermont & Boston, Kentucky
* Old Heaven Hill - Heaven Hill Distillery, Bardstown, Kentucky
* Old Kentucky - Bardstown, Kentucky
* Old Pogue - Bardstown, Kentucky
* Old Rip Van Winkle — Buffalo Trace Distillery, Frankfort, Kentucky
* Old Taylor - Jim Beam Distilleries, Clermont & Boston, Kentucky
* Pappy Van Winkle - Old Rip VanWinkle Distillery, Louisville, Kentucky
* Old Weller - Buffalo Trace Distillery, Frankfort, Kentucky
* Pure Kentucky - Bardstown, Kentucky
* Rebel Yell — Bernheim Distillery, Louisville, Kentucky
* Rock Hill Farms Single-Barrel - Buffalo Trace Distillery, Frankfort, Kentucky
* Sam Houston - Louisville, Kentucky
* Ten High — Barton Distillery, Bardstown, Kentucky
* Tom Moore - Barton Distillery, Bardstown, Kentucky
* T. W. Samuels, Heaven Hill Distillery, Bardstown, Kentucky
* Very Old Barton - Barton Distillery, Bardstown, Kentucky
* Wathen's - Charles Medley Distillery, Owensboro, Kentucky
* Straight Old Kentucky
* Wild Turkey — Wild Turkey Distillery, Lawrenceburg, Kentucky
* Willett — Willet family Distillery, Bardstown, Kentucky
* W.L. Weller — Buffalo Trace Distillery, Frankfort, Kentucky
* Woodford Reserve — Woodford Reserve Distillery, Versailles, Kentucky

Non-Kentucky Bourbons

* A. H. Hirsch - Michter's, near Shaeffestown, Pennsylvania [closed, but still available]
* Bowman's — A. Smith Bowman Distillery, Fredericksburg, Virginia
* Most Wanted - High Plains Distillery, Atchison, Kansas
* Sam Cougar - Seagrams Distillery, Lawrenceburg, Indiana
* Tuthilltown Hudson Baby, Tuthilltown Spirits, New York
* Virginia Gentleman — A. Smith Bowman Distillery, Fredericksburg, Virginia
* Woodstone Creek - Woodstone Creek, Cincinnati, Ohio

Bourbons from Unknown distilleries

* Woodstock

Tennessee Whiskey


* Jack Daniel's
* George Dickel
* Gentleman Jack

Rye Whiskey


* Heaven Hill Vintage
* Hirsch Vintage
* Hudson Manhattan
* Jim Beam Rye
* Jack Daniel's Rye
* Michters
* Old Overholt
* Old Potrero
* Pikesville
* Red Hook
* Rendezvous Rye Whiskey
* Rittenhouse
* Sazerac
* Templeton Rye
* Van Winkle Family Reserve Rye
* Wild Turkey Rye

Wheat Whiskey

* Bernheim Original - Heaven Hill Distillery, Bardstown, Kentucky

Australian whisky brands

* Hellyer's Road / Southern Fire Single Malt Whisky, Tasmania

Canadian whisky brands


* Glenora Distillers, Glenville, Nova Scotia (independent)
o Glen Breton Rare
o Glen Breton Ice 10 Year
o Glen Breton Ice 15 Year

Canadian blended whisky

* Alberta Distillers, Calgary (independent)
o Alberta Premium
o Alberta Premium 25 Years Old
o Alberta Springs Rye Whisky 10 Years Old
o Alberta Springs Rye Whisky 25 Years Old
o Tangle Ridge Aged 10 Years

* Allied Domecq
o McGuinness Silk Tassel

* Barton Brands
o Barton's Canadian 36 Months Old
o Canadian Host
o Canadian Supreme
o Corby's Canadian 36 Months Old
o McMaster's
o Northern Lights

* Canadian Mist Distillers, Collingwood, Ontario (Brown-Forman)
o Canadian Mist

* Century Distilling, Vancouver
o Century Reserve 8 Year Old
o Century Reserve 13 Year Old
o Century Reserve 15 Year Old
o Century Reserve 21 Year Old

* Corby Distilleries, Toronto (Allied)
o Gooderham & Worts Ltd
o Lot No. 40
o Pike Creek
o Royal Reserve
o Royal Reserve Gold

* Diageo
o Crown Royal
o Crown Royal Limited Edition
o Crown Royal Special Reserve
o Crown Royal XR
o Crown Royal Cask 16
o Seagram's 83 Canadian Whisky
o Seagram's Five Star Rye Whisky
o Seagram's Seven Crown
o Seagram's VO
o Seagram's VO Gold

* Highwood Distillery, High River, Alberta
o Centennial 10 Year Old Rye Whisky
o Highwood Canadian Rye Whisky
o Saskatchewan Wheatland Rye Whisky

* Hiram Walker (Allied)
o Canadian Club Premium
o Canadian Club Sherry Cask Aged Eight Years
o Canadian Club Reserve 10 Years of Age
o Canadian Club Premium Classic Aged 12 Years
o Hiram Walker Special Old Rye Whisky
o Wiser's Deluxe
o Wiser's Deluxe 10 Years Old
o Wiser's Very Old
o Wiser's Special Blend
o Wiser's Reserve
o Wiser's Small Batch
o Rich & Rare

* Hood River Distillers
o Pendleton

* Kittling Ridge (independent)
o Forty Creek Barrel Select
o Forty Creek Port Wood Reserve
o Forty Creek Small Batch Reserve
o Forty Creek Three Grain
o Mountain Rock
o Pure Gold

* Maple Leaf Distillers, Winnipeg
o Canadian Cellars Rye Whisky

* Schenley Industries (Barton)
o Black Velvet DeLuxe
o Gibson's Finest Aged 12 Years
o Gibson's Finest Rare Aged 18 Years
o Gibson's Finest Sterling Edition
o Schenley Golden Wedding
o Schenley OFC Aged 8 Years

* Williams & Churchill Ltd., Quebec/Alberta
o Danfield's Small Batch Private Reserve
o Danfield's Small Batch 21 Years Old

* Windsor Distillary
o Windsor Canadian

Finnish Whisky Brands


* Panimoravintola Beer Hunter's
o Old Buck
* Teerenpeli
o Teerenpeli Single Malt

German Whisky Brands


* Blaue Maus
o Grüner Hund Vintage 1991
o Blaue Maus Vintage 1993
o Krottentaler Vintage 1994
o Schwartzer Pirat Vintage 1995
o Spinnaker 1997
* Gruel
o Gruel Single Grain Whisky 5 Year Old
o Gruel Single Grain Whisky 7 Year Old
o Gruel Single Grain Whisky 9 Year Old
* Höhler
o Whessky, Irish Style
o Whessky, Scottish Style Single Malt
o Whessky, Rye Style
o Whessky, Bourbon Style
o Whessky, Bourbon Style Cask Strength
* Rabel
o Schwäbischer
o Whisky von der Alb
* Reiner Mösslein
o Fränkisher Whiskey
* Slyrs
o Slyrs Bavarian Single Malt
* Sonnenschein
o Sonnenschein 10 Year Old Single Malt
* Volker Theurer
o Black Horse Original Ammertal Whiskey

Irish Whiskey Brands


Irish Single Malts

* Brogan's Legacy Irish Single Malt
* A Drop of the Irish
* Bushmills Ten Year Old
* Bushmills Sixteen Year Old
* Cadenhead's Peated Single Malt
* Clonmel Single Malt
* Connemara
* Erin Go Bragh
* Knappogue Castle
* Locke's Single Malt
* Merrys Single Malt
* Michael Collins Single Malt
* Preston Millennium Malt
* Shanahans
* Shannon Grain Single Malt
* Slaney Malt
* Suir Peated Malt
* The Irishman Single Malt
* Tyrconnell

Pure Pot Still Whiskeys

* Green Spot
* Daly's of Tullamore
* Dungourney 1964
* Dunville's VR
* Dunville's Three Crowns
* Jameson 15 Year Old Pot Still
* Magilligan
* Midleton 25 Year Old
* Midleton 30 Year Old
* Old Comber
* Redbreast (whiskey)
* Willie Napier 1945

Blended Irish Whiskeys

* Avoca (whiskey)
* Baileys Irish Whiskey (not currently available)
* Ballygeary
* Brennans
* Bushmills White Bush
* Bushmills Black Bush
* Bushmills 1608
* Cassidy's
* Coleraine
* Clontarf
* Crested Ten
* Dunphys
* Erin's Isle
* Feckin Irish Whiskey
* Golden Irish
* Grace
* Hewitts
* Inishowen
* Jameson Irish Whiskey
* Jameson 1780 (replaced Jameson 12 Year Old)
* Jameson Distillery Reserve
* Jameson Gold
* Kilbeggan
* Locke's
* Michael Collins Blend
* Midleton Very Rare
* Millars
* Murphy's
* Old Kilkenny
* O'Briens
* O'Neills
* Old Dublin
* Paddy
* Powers Gold Label
* Red Breast Blend
* Strangford Gold
* The Irishman
* Tullamore Dew
* Wild Geese

Single Grain Irish Whiskeys

* Greenore

Japanese whisky brands

* Nikka
o Yoichi
o Miyagikyo
o Black Nikka
o Taketsuru
* Suntory
o Yamazaki
o Hakushu
o Hibiki
o Hokuto
o Kaku

New Zealand whisky brands


* Milford

Scotch Whisky Brands

Single Malt Scotch


* Aberfeldy
* Aberlour
* Allt-A-Bhainne
* Ardbeg
* Ardmore
* Arran
* Auchentoshan
* Auchroisk
* Aultmore
* Balblair
* Balmenach
* The Balvenie
* Bell's & Sons
* Banff
* Ben Nevis
* BenRiach
* Benrinnes
* Benromach
* Bladnoch
* Blair Athol
* Bowmore
* Brackla
* Braeval
* Brora
* Bruichladdich
* Bunnahabhain
* Caol Ila
* Caperdonich
* Cardhu
* Clynelish
* An Cnoc
* Coleburn
* Convalmore
* Cragganmore
* Craigellachie
* Dailuaine
* Dallas Dhu
* The Dalmore
* Dalwhinnie
* Deanston
* Drumguish
* Dufftown
* Edradour
* Fettercairn
* Glen Albyn
* Glenallachie
* Glenburgie
* Glencadam
* Glen Deveron
* Glendronach
* Glendullan
* Glen Elgin
* Glenesk
* Glenfarclas
* Glenfiddich
* Glen Flagler
* Glen Garioch
* Glenglassaugh
* Glengoyne
* Glen Grant
* Glen Keith
* Glenkinchie
* The Glenlivet
* Glenlochy
* Glenlossie
* Glen Mhor
* Glenmorangie
* Glen Moray
* Glen Ord
* Glenrothes
* Glen Scotia
* Glen Spey
* Glentauchers
* Glenturret
* Glen Turner (whisky)
* Glenugie
* Glenury Royal
* Highland Park
* Imperial
* Inchgower
* Inverleven
* Isle of Jura
* Kilchoman
* Kinclaith
* Knockdhu
* Knockando
* Ladyburn
* Lagavulin
* Laphroaig
* Ledaig
* Linkwood
* Littlemill
* Loch Lomond
* Lochnagar
* Longmorn
* The Macallan
* Mannochmore
* McClelland
* Millburn
* Miltonduff
* Mortlach
* North Port
* Oban
* Pittyvaich
* Port Ellen
* Port Charlotte
* Old Pulteney
* Royal Brackla
* Rosebank
* St Magdalene
* Scapa
* The Singleton
* Speyburn
* Springbank
* Strathisla
* Strathmill
* Talisker
* Tamdhu
* Tamnavulin
* Teaninich
* Tobermory
* Tomatin
* Tomintoul
* Tormore
* Tullibardine
* William Grant & Sons

Grain Scotch Whisky

* North British Grain
* Cameron Brig (Cameron Bridge Distillery)

and many more

[Parshooter]

My fav is the Macallan Cask Strength

[mithrilG60]

Originally Posted by steveljohn8

Dear All Members ,

Here are some of the Manufactures of Excellent Scotch Whiskeys:

<snip, snip>

Scotch Whisky Brands

Single Malt Scotch


* Aberfeldy
* Aberlour
* Allt-A-Bhainne
* Ardbeg
* Ardmore
* Arran
* Auchentoshan
* Auchroisk
* Aultmore
* Balblair
* Balmenach
* The Balvenie
* Bell's & Sons
* Banff
* Ben Nevis
* BenRiach
* Benrinnes
* Benromach
* Bladnoch
* Blair Athol
* Bowmore
* Brackla
* Braeval
* Brora
* Bruichladdich
* Bunnahabhain
* Caol Ila
* Caperdonich
* Cardhu
* Clynelish
* An Cnoc
* Coleburn
* Convalmore
* Cragganmore
* Craigellachie
* Dailuaine
* Dallas Dhu
* The Dalmore
* Dalwhinnie
* Deanston
* Drumguish
* Dufftown
* Edradour
* Fettercairn
* Glen Albyn
* Glenallachie
* Glenburgie
* Glencadam
* Glen Deveron
* Glendronach
* Glendullan
* Glen Elgin
* Glenesk
* Glenfarclas
* Glenfiddich
* Glen Flagler
* Glen Garioch
* Glenglassaugh
* Glengoyne
* Glen Grant
* Glen Keith
* Glenkinchie
* The Glenlivet
* Glenlochy
* Glenlossie
* Glen Mhor
* Glenmorangie
* Glen Moray
* Glen Ord
* Glenrothes
* Glen Scotia
* Glen Spey
* Glentauchers
* Glenturret
* Glen Turner (whisky)
* Glenugie
* Glenury Royal
* Highland Park
* Imperial
* Inchgower
* Inverleven
* Isle of Jura
* Kilchoman
* Kinclaith
* Knockdhu
* Knockando
* Ladyburn
* Lagavulin
* Laphroaig
* Ledaig
* Linkwood
* Littlemill
* Loch Lomond
* Lochnagar
* Longmorn
* The Macallan
* Mannochmore
* McClelland
* Millburn
* Miltonduff
* Mortlach
* North Port
* Oban
* Pittyvaich
* Port Ellen
* Port Charlotte
* Old Pulteney
* Royal Brackla
* Rosebank
* St Magdalene
* Scapa
* The Singleton
* Speyburn
* Springbank
* Strathisla
* Strathmill
* Talisker
* Tamdhu
* Tamnavulin
* Teaninich
* Tobermory
* Tomatin
* Tomintoul
* Tormore
* Tullibardine
* William Grant & Sons

Grain Scotch Whisky

* North British Grain
* Cameron Brig (Cameron Bridge Distillery)

Not to be technical, but these are the only ones in your list which are actually Scotch Whisky. To be considered Scotch Whisky it must be distilled, aged and bottled in Scotland; every other whisky that doesn't mean that requirement is not scotch.

[SmokeyJoe]

Have become a fan of this reasonably priced single malt...



Speyburn 10 Year. A real bargain IMHO.

I love Glenlivet 18, Nadurra, Glenfiddich 12, but this Speyburn compares favorably.

Picked up one of my favs a couple of days ago. Ardbeg 10. long over due for opening it.

[yourchoice]

Originally Posted by SmokeyJoe

Have become a fan of this reasonably priced single malt...

Speyburn 10 Year. A real bargain IMHO.

I love Glenlivet 18, Nadurra, Glenfiddich 12, but this Speyburn compares favorably.

Very good for the $. Unfortunately my hand continually gravitates toward my Lagavulin, Ardbeg and Bowmore... then my wallet.

I like peat...can you tell?

[macpappy]

all of the above

[CEC_Tech]

Originally Posted by SmokeyJoe

Have become a fan of this reasonably priced single malt...



Speyburn 10 Year. A real bargain IMHO.

I love Glenlivet 18, Nadurra, Glenfiddich 12, but this Speyburn compares favorably.

This is a good one. Very good if you're just starting to dabble as well. It's got a clean finish and not overpowering at all.

[scoot]

Originally Posted by s0leful0ne

I've decided to dabble into this scotch business. Is there any that you guys recommend I start tasting?

The McClelland's is good for what it is, but keep in mind that it is a younger version of other Bowmore owned whiskeys. I believe they're all five years old, aside from the Speyside 12. Given the age you might find it to be a bit rough around the edges.

Look for a few of the glens to start. You should be able to find Glenfiddich 12 for under 40. Its a good jumping off point. It has nice flavor but won't overwhelm an unfamiliar pallet.

[CBI_2]

Glenlivet 18yr. is the best I have had.

Glen Moray 12yr. for $19.99 is very good.

For a blended Grant's is very good. Nice and smooth. It is produced by the makers of Glenfiddich.

[DAFU]

Highland Park 12 YO is a great all round pour. Gracefully aged in oak casks it exhibits a nice balance of peaty smokiness and heathery sweetness.