Most overrated cigar you've ever smoked?

Dude Here · 11-06-2013, 09:47 PM

So we've all seen cigar advertising before. Beautiful pictures of cigars with wrappers emmiting an oily sheen. Usually a quote or two from some cigar industry higher up proclaiming how it's the best smoke they've ever had. And, more often then not, some sort of 90+ rating proudly displayed on the page. So one day you're out shopping, either online or at your B&M and you see it. That beautiful stick that garnered such praise and adulation that you can't help. It buy one (that $15 price tag be damned). A few hours (or days, weeks, months) later you're sitting down for a smoke, it's time to see what all the fuss was about. You light that bad boy up and............it stinks. Either the burn is terrible, it's poorly constructed or the flavors just plain suck. "But wait", you think to yourself, "this thing is supposed to be awesome, what happened here?" This ever happen to you?

For me this has been the story of the Ashton VSG. I have never had one that burned or drew correctly. Normally I would just think a bad box, right? However these were three different sticks, from three different retailers and they all had similar issues. Really frustrating considering the price tag these cigars carry. So, I pose the question to you my fellow cigar enthusiasts, what's the most overrated, underperforming cigar you've ever had?

MUNKY · 11-06-2013, 10:01 PM

Romeo, thing had mad rave reviews and boat loads of hype and thing was like eating a mouthful of charcoal to me. Totally disappointed I bought into the hype...

Dude Here · 11-06-2013, 10:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MUNKY

Romeo, thing had mad rave reviews and boat loads of hype and thing was like eating a mouthful of charcoal to me. Totally disappointed I bought into the hype...

I see those things EVERYWHERE. I've only had one RyJ before, years and years ago, and remember that is was like sucking ashy air through a straw. Haven't tried another one since.

JenksAnejo · 11-06-2013, 10:15 PM

Any Rocky Patel.. A bunch of guys at my B&M talk these up like they are the best cigars on the face of the earth... The only one I can stand is the decade but that's it.

I agree with the Romeo being overated as well. Heard nothing but rave reviews and I didn't even make it 15 mins in before pitching it.

T.G · 11-06-2013, 11:29 PM

The Gurkha that icehog3 recommend I try.

MrClean · 11-07-2013, 12:00 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by T.G

The Gurkha that icehog3 recommend I try.

I haven't been smoking that long (2 years), I've definitely had some that I didn't care for or that I pitched after the first 1/3. But other than a few Rocky Patel sticks that I didn't care for I haven't had that big let down. I know it'll happen eventually.

icehog3 · 11-07-2013, 12:49 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by T.G

The Gurkha that icehog3 recommend I try.

Et tu, Adam, et tu?

Any one of the Tatuaje Monsters....special mention to the megacrapilicious "Face".

Gabe215 · 11-07-2013, 02:25 AM

Love this thread and glad to be part if it to see more comments people make! I know people will disagree with my post but here it is, all of Liga Privada Unico Series, I smoked pretty much all of it, hunted and tracked down all their offerings and what I found was it all kinda tasted the same. And the price put the foulest taste in my mouth, Dirty rats aren't bad but $13 a piece hell no! Tatuaje makes one of my favorite NC's Reserva SW, but... A lot of his stuff like DE use gimmicks and are way overhyped, everyone is on Jd's and PJ's balls!

Simpleman · 11-07-2013, 02:36 AM

I really disliked most AJF cigars.

Porch Dweller · 11-07-2013, 06:35 AM

Liga Privada #9.

Blak Smyth · 11-07-2013, 06:46 AM

Viaje Holiday Blend
T52 Flying Pig

dave · 11-07-2013, 07:58 AM

Overated: The cigars I didn't like.

Honestly, I don't begrudge those that like what they like. Last week I sat with an old friend who was having an RP 1990 and absolutely loved it. I haven't considered buying one in more than 6 years -- but, to him it certainly wasn't overated. I'd be more interested in how you judge what is overated.....are you comparing your taste with the reviews here and in other 'respected' forums? Or with advertising hype and CA ratings? I'm more likely to compare my personal assessment with that of the BOTL here. When using CA (and one or two other forums) for benchmarking, I don't know of any cigars that I'd cite as highly overated.

czerbe · 11-07-2013, 08:21 AM

If I have to pick one its a LPFFP it wasn't bad and the construction was great but lacked flavor in my opinion now I would like to try another one maybe it was just a bum stick but they are MIA in my area and I really don't want to pull the trigger on something that pricey.

BryanB · 11-07-2013, 08:32 AM

Opus X....any size.

chaase321 · 11-07-2013, 08:43 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Blak Smyth

T52 Flying Pig

100% Agree ^^^

Quote:

Originally Posted by BryanB

Opus X....any size.

Also agree that these are WAY WAY over hyped, but I also don't care for anything Dominican, so i can't say too much bad about just the Opus line

CigarSquid · 11-07-2013, 08:50 AM

I had a God of Fire I hung on to for a couple of months, waiting for a good day to smoke it. I decided to break it out while at my fathers house, first time we smoked together.

Just a BLAH kinda smoke.. was no impressed. I wanted to toss it, but it wasn't bad, just way under.... taste.

It was gifted to me. I do not see the 25-29 dollar price tag for how it was. I am glad I didn't pay for it.

AdamJoshua · 11-07-2013, 09:32 AM

Drew Estate Papas Fritas

I remember when these were all the rage so I picked some up, I should have left them down. Not impressed at all.

Remo · 11-07-2013, 09:51 AM

Most overrated that I have personally smoked are:

Padron Anny Serie (all) good smokes just thought that they would be EPIC based on the hype.

Opus X..again good smoke but not a mind blower for what the hype is about.

Hyperbole....it's the best thing ever!!!!

Blak Smyth · 11-07-2013, 09:57 AM

I agree on all the Opus X references. There may not be a more hyped "premium" cigar out there that has been more of a dissapointment.

Remo · 11-07-2013, 10:04 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Blak Smyth

I agree on all the Opus X references. There may not be a more hyped "premium" cigar out there that has been more of a dissapointment.

I have a God of Fire that has been down for a few years, hoping it is hype worthy

11-06-2013, 09:47 PM	#1
Dude Here I'm the Dude...Man! Join Date: Oct 2013 First Name: Steve Location: Texas Posts: 671 Trading: (3)	Most overrated cigar you've ever smoked? So we've all seen cigar advertising before. Beautiful pictures of cigars with wrappers emmiting an oily sheen. Usually a quote or two from some cigar industry higher up proclaiming how it's the best smoke they've ever had. And, more often then not, some sort of 90+ rating proudly displayed on the page. So one day you're out shopping, either online or at your B&M and you see it. That beautiful stick that garnered such praise and adulation that you can't help. It buy one (that $15 price tag be damned). A few hours (or days, weeks, months) later you're sitting down for a smoke, it's time to see what all the fuss was about. You light that bad boy up and............it stinks. Either the burn is terrible, it's poorly constructed or the flavors just plain suck. "But wait", you think to yourself, "this thing is supposed to be awesome, what happened here?" This ever happen to you? For me this has been the story of the Ashton VSG. I have never had one that burned or drew correctly. Normally I would just think a bad box, right? However these were three different sticks, from three different retailers and they all had similar issues. Really frustrating considering the price tag these cigars carry. So, I pose the question to you my fellow cigar enthusiasts, what's the most overrated, underperforming cigar you've ever had?

11-06-2013, 10:01 PM	#2
MUNKY Resident Pig Hunter Join Date: May 2013 First Name: Brandon Location: Pearland, TX Posts: 1,169 Trading: (19)	Re: Most overrated cigar you've ever smoked? Romeo, thing had mad rave reviews and boat loads of hype and thing was like eating a mouthful of charcoal to me. Totally disappointed I bought into the hype... __________________ Proud member of the GMCGTPWHAFA

11-06-2013, 10:15 PM	#4
JenksAnejo Thunder Up Join Date: Dec 2011 First Name: Jarrod Location: Thunder Country Posts: 1,332 Trading: (51)	Re: Most overrated cigar you've ever smoked? Any Rocky Patel.. A bunch of guys at my B&M talk these up like they are the best cigars on the face of the earth... The only one I can stand is the decade but that's it. I agree with the Romeo being overated as well. Heard nothing but rave reviews and I didn't even make it 15 mins in before pitching it.

11-06-2013, 11:29 PM	#5
T.G Grrrrrr Join Date: Mar 2009 First Name: The Other Adam Posts: 15,557 Trading: (37)	Re: Most overrated cigar you've ever smoked? The Gurkha that icehog3 recommend I try.

11-07-2013, 02:25 AM	#8
Gabe215 Have My Own Room Join Date: Nov 2012 First Name: Gabe Location: Philadelphia Posts: 1,120 Trading: (20)	Re: Most overrated cigar you've ever smoked? Love this thread and glad to be part if it to see more comments people make! I know people will disagree with my post but here it is, all of Liga Privada Unico Series, I smoked pretty much all of it, hunted and tracked down all their offerings and what I found was it all kinda tasted the same. And the price put the foulest taste in my mouth, Dirty rats aren't bad but $13 a piece hell no! Tatuaje makes one of my favorite NC's Reserva SW, but... A lot of his stuff like DE use gimmicks and are way overhyped, everyone is on Jd's and PJ's balls!

11-07-2013, 02:36 AM	#9
Simpleman Just in from the Storm Join Date: Mar 2013 Location: West central Mn Posts: 22 Trading: (0)	Re: Most overrated cigar you've ever smoked? I really disliked most AJF cigars.

11-07-2013, 06:35 AM	#10
Porch Dweller Life is for living Join Date: Oct 2012 First Name: James Location: Mississippi Gulf Coast Posts: 8,401 Trading: (24)	Re: Most overrated cigar you've ever smoked? Liga Privada #9. __________________ A 1911 in the hand is faster than 911 on the phone

11-07-2013, 06:46 AM	#11
Blak Smyth Think Blue! Join Date: Jun 2011 First Name: SD Location: THE WOOD Posts: 8,486 Trading: (52)	Re: Most overrated cigar you've ever smoked? Viaje Holiday Blend T52 Flying Pig __________________ SUPPORT OUR TROOPS

11-07-2013, 07:58 AM	#12
dave Have My Own Room Join Date: May 2011 First Name: Dave Location: Northern VA Posts: 1,180 Trading: (15)	Re: Most overrated cigar you've ever smoked? Overated: The cigars I didn't like. Honestly, I don't begrudge those that like what they like. Last week I sat with an old friend who was having an RP 1990 and absolutely loved it. I haven't considered buying one in more than 6 years -- but, to him it certainly wasn't overated. I'd be more interested in how you judge what is overated.....are you comparing your taste with the reviews here and in other 'respected' forums? Or with advertising hype and CA ratings? I'm more likely to compare my personal assessment with that of the BOTL here. When using CA (and one or two other forums) for benchmarking, I don't know of any cigars that I'd cite as highly overated. __________________ I would rather be exposed to the inconveniences attending too much liberty than to those attending too small a degree of it. Thomas Jefferson

11-07-2013, 08:21 AM	#13
czerbe Just a Traveling Man Join Date: Apr 2012 First Name: Corey Location: Reading Pa Posts: 1,309 Trading: (2)	Re: Most overrated cigar you've ever smoked? If I have to pick one its a LPFFP it wasn't bad and the construction was great but lacked flavor in my opinion now I would like to try another one maybe it was just a bum stick but they are MIA in my area and I really don't want to pull the trigger on something that pricey. __________________ Live fast, hard, everyday like its your last.

11-07-2013, 08:32 AM	#14
BryanB Have My Own Room Join Date: Nov 2008 First Name: Bryan Location: Benson, NC Posts: 1,177 Trading: (58)	Re: Most overrated cigar you've ever smoked? Opus X....any size. __________________ "Cheap cigars come in handy; they stifle the odor of cheap politicians." Ulysses S. Grant

11-07-2013, 08:50 AM	#16
CigarSquid AKA Garryyjr Join Date: Apr 2011 First Name: Garry Location: Medford, OR - Cigar Zombie Posts: 3,213 Trading: (39)	Re: Most overrated cigar you've ever smoked? I had a God of Fire I hung on to for a couple of months, waiting for a good day to smoke it. I decided to break it out while at my fathers house, first time we smoked together. Just a BLAH kinda smoke.. was no impressed. I wanted to toss it, but it wasn't bad, just way under.... taste. It was gifted to me. I do not see the 25-29 dollar price tag for how it was. I am glad I didn't pay for it. __________________ gaRRy

11-07-2013, 09:32 AM	#17
AdamJoshua Article 4 Free Inhabitant Join Date: Jan 2013 First Name: The Other Adam Location: Satellite Beach Posts: 14,787 Trading: (40)	Re: Most overrated cigar you've ever smoked? Drew Estate Papas Fritas I remember when these were all the rage so I picked some up, I should have left them down. Not impressed at all.

11-07-2013, 09:51 AM	#18
Remo C.I.A Join Date: Feb 2011 First Name: Mike Location: Palm Harbor, Florida Posts: 12,597 Trading: (122)	Re: Most overrated cigar you've ever smoked? Most overrated that I have personally smoked are: Padron Anny Serie (all) good smokes just thought that they would be EPIC based on the hype. Opus X..again good smoke but not a mind blower for what the hype is about. Hyperbole....it's the best thing ever!!!! __________________

11-07-2013, 09:57 AM	#19
Blak Smyth Think Blue! Join Date: Jun 2011 First Name: SD Location: THE WOOD Posts: 8,486 Trading: (52)	Re: Most overrated cigar you've ever smoked? I agree on all the Opus X references. There may not be a more hyped "premium" cigar out there that has been more of a dissapointment. __________________ SUPPORT OUR TROOPS