torch and cutter, in flight carry on?

[Devanmc]

Originally Posted by bvilchez

Same as everyone said above but don't think that just because you're in uniform you'll get some slack.

Yeah i understand. I was just mentioning it because previously i have gotten slack(lack of them really checking my stuff) because i was in uniform. Idk if thats normal but it was worth mentioning.

[Bill86]

Originally Posted by Chingas

Agreed!

Cheap cutter, cheap lighter or buy it there and toss it.

I've never had a problem with either but it's not worth it. I deal with the same crap cause I carry two pocket knives, always. So I leave them in the car and buy some cheapies when I land. I gift them before I get back on the plane to go home.

I hear ya, I wouldn't even THINK to take my Strider SMF on the plane with me. I would mail you're good **** to where ever you go.....cutters/lighters/knives whatever....and mail it back to your house afterwards. Especially if you're staying a few weeks. What does it cost $5-$7 bucks both ways? Don't risk your good stuff, ship it or don't but there's always cheapies that will get you by.

[forgop]

Originally Posted by icehog3

Yup, it can be a crapshoot with the TSA agents who don't understand their own policies...so I don't chance it with my good cutters.

I'd pull this up on my iPhone real quick if some TSA idiot wanted to pull my cutter out of my carry on:

http://www.tsa.gov/assets/pdf/prohib...s_10-24-07.pdf

[forgop]

Originally Posted by sevans105

Guillotine cutters can (and probably will) be snagged. Have never had a problem with a punch cutter...especially one on a key chain and I fly 2 to 3 times a week with it. Get a good punch cutter, get used to using it and buy a Jetlite for 4 bucks at walmart when you arrive.

Back in '99, I was going through customs while on military orders in Germany. I played hell getting that through even though I opened it up to show them it wasn't a real casing.

[sevans105]

Originally Posted by forgop

Back in '99, I was going through customs while on military orders in Germany. I played hell getting that through even though I opened it up to show them it wasn't a real casing.

Lol. Yeah. Probably not a good idea to get one shaped like an actual bullet! Cool for home, crappy for travel.

[icehog3]

Originally Posted by forgop

I'd pull this up on my iPhone real quick if some TSA idiot wanted to pull my cutter out of my carry on:

http://www.tsa.gov/assets/pdf/prohib...s_10-24-07.pdf

Good luck "reasoning" with an uptight TSA agent.

[Mugen910]

Originally Posted by icehog3

Good luck "reasoning" with an uptight TSA agent.

it's not worth the hassle or fight. Just get on the plane and spend the $ when you land.

[aich75013]

Last time I went to Vegas, I tossed a cheap cutter in my travel humi which was in my carry-on.
I didn't have any issues, but I didn't really care if they took it. I wasn't going to risk my Palio or Xikar and I'm not going to argue with the TSA Agent.

I was meeting a friend in Vegas who had a lighter, so I didn't bother trying to take one. Backup plan was to buy a cheapie there.

[Devanmc]

Originally Posted by dwoodward

Hehe, better bring a cigar FOR her dad.

that indeed is the plan. bringing 4sticks back with me.

[lbowles2]

Originally Posted by icehog3

Unless they are in one of the approved containers that conform to DOT-SP 14327. I have one made by Colibri.

Hehe... I just got done posting this on another thread

I have used one of these a couple of times with no problem. I just packed it in my check-in luggage. I kind of doubt it would be allowed in carry on though.

Why not just pre-cut the cigars before packing them? You can even check for a surprise draw problem before you leave.
xD

[tsolomon]

My wife has been traveling a lot lately with her Xikar cutter in her purse and they finally caught it last week on her way to SLC. A number of the TSA agents looked it over and then allowed her to keep it. She stored in her checked bag for the trip home.

If it were an open blade, it would be much different. however, the only real damage you could do with a cutter would be the removal of fingers and toes. It would be very hard to take over a plane with a cutter.

[aich75013]

Originally Posted by itzfrank

If it were an open blade, it would be much different. however, the only real damage you could do with a cutter would be the removal of fingers and toes. It would be very hard to take over a plane with a cutter.

I'd like to see that explanation to the TSA Agent. "Oh come on, the worst I could do is cut off a finger or toe."

[bobarian]

Originally Posted by itzfrank

If it were an open blade, it would be much different. however, the only real damage you could do with a cutter would be the removal of fingers and toes. It would be very hard to take over a plane with a cutter.

Originally Posted by aich75013

I'd like to see that explanation to the TSA Agent. "Oh come on, the worst I could do is cut off a finger or toe."

TSA agents can act at their own discretion, they do not need to explain their decisions. They can confiscate items even if they are on the approved list. I am not sure why you would risk anything of value just to "test" the system.

[aich75013]

Originally Posted by bobarian

TSA agents can act at their own discretion, they do not need to explain their decisions. They can confiscate items even if they are on the approved list. I am not sure why you would risk anything of value just to "test" the system.

I had a small pocket knife in my backpack once.
The agent asked me about it and gave me the option of mailing it home. She was very nice. I explained it was a cheap pocket knife and not worth the cost of shipping.

[St. Lou Stu]

Originally Posted by itzfrank

If it were an open blade, it would be much different. however, the only real damage you could do with a cutter would be the removal of fingers and toes. It would be very hard to take over a plane with a cutter.

If you were going to cut one of my digits off I would hand the plane over.

[icehog3]

Originally Posted by lbowles2

Hehe... I just got done posting this on another thread

I have used one of these a couple of times with no problem. I just packed it in my check-in luggage. I kind of doubt it would be allowed in carry on though.

Correct....Checked luggage only.

Originally Posted by Devanmc

Well Im planning a trip home to visit my girl and family. Going to bring a few sticks back with me in a small travelador, which should be no problem at all. I am concerned however, about bringing my new xikar Xi2 and torch on the flight with me as im only bringing 1 bag(my carry on). Whats been everyone's experience with security handling cigar cutters and torches?

Note: security will be a bit lighter on me as i am military traveling in uniform.

Don't risk either, regulation says the cutter should be fine. However, my sister was TSA or whatever and out of confusion or trolling they would take them from people all the time. Half the time the guards are shady and if they can make sense out of confiscating something that's perfectly okay to have they will just so they can have it for themselves.

Originally Posted by icehog3

Unless they are in one of the approved containers that conform to DOT-SP 14327. I have one made by Colibri.

I Never had this problem the last 2 or so years on transatlantic flights. I put my torch in my toiletry bag, and the bag in my check-in luggage. Guess I should be more careful next time.