Tat RC 184 w/ pics as always!

cigarmonkel · 11-02-2009, 11:57 PM

So I've moved into a new condo with some buddies who all smoke their own kinda tobaccy. So i started saying well.. im gonna smoke my real tobaccy then in my room. Lit some smell good sticks and opened the window and the smell doesn't reach them. My room is on the ground level, they're on the 3rd floor with the kitchen and living room area on the 2nd floor. Anyways to the point of this thread!

I've had this sitting in my vinotemp/humidor for quite sometime now. I was lucky enough to have this from a bomb (not sure who bombed it to me and i deeply apologize!)

Appearance: This cigar comes with a shiny silver tin foil wrapping on it (fun for us ADD folk). The wrapper is full of veins, and is surprisingly light. The cap is very nice and has what looks like up to 5 in some spots..

pre-light: It has a very mild smell to it and im hoping this is not a mild cigar. I've done very little research on this cigar so i have no clue what to expect.. hopefully this way i won't have any biased opinions about it.

The pre-light draw is very easy and takes very little effect. I'm getting very subtle hints of some sort of wood flavor, and again i'm getting the feeling this is going to be a fairly mild cigar.

Initial light: The first puffs taste like nothing but wood, the draw is still extremely easy. the smoke isn't very dense or thick. There are some after flavors which i am having a hard time identifying and are new to me.

By now its produced a pretty steady flavor. It has a very smooth earthy flavor, almost reminds me of one of the taboo cigars but cannot remember which one for the life of me. The draw is still very open and easy to grab a lot of smoke. Its also producing a lot more smoke too, not very thick but enough to keep me pleased. This is definitely a more mild smoke. I tend to like my mild smokes earlier in the morning with some coffee and seeing as this stick is a pretty good size probably wouldn't smoke it in the morning.

http://i257.photobucket.com/albums/h...Picture073.jpg

After about an inch in... this cigar isn't for me.
A. its too mild, even if i was to smoke this in the morning it would be too big of a smoke for me in the morning.
B. It doesn't seem to wanna hold its flavor as much as i would think from a more rarely seen and smoked cigar.... which maybe is the reason you don't see this being lit up all the time?

I'm giving it another chance. Gonna stick with it for a little longer and see how things play out. The taste has picked up more and seems to be... "in the sense" or "more there then not".. if that makes any sense at all. I guess what im trying to say is the flavor is standing out a lot more now. Before i almost felt like i had to sit there, smack my lips a little bit and really search for something. But now its like "Hi my name is flavor".
By no means am i saying this cigar has an extreme amount of flavor but compared to when i first lit it... its like a whole new cigar. The flavors i'm getting have gone back to a wood taste with some earthy undertones and a very subtle hint of what seems to be carmel?
The burn is staying extremely even which surprises me. The tip you light resembled a fig. roll of a cigar and they never seem to burn evenly for me and i always have to touch it up to get it to burn right. The draw is still perfect in my book. The lighter the draw the better IMO and the smoke is pretty decent. Not as thick as the Illusione MK i had smoked earlier today but still enough to blow smoke rings with and watch it bellow out of your mouth.
About 1 inch later this cigar has changed my mind. Good thing i stuck with it (lesson learned). This cigar has completely changed and has gone to a more medium bodied smoke, the flavors seem to just get upfront with every puff i take. the burn is still incredible even and the draw has tightened up just a tad but not nearly enough for me to make any complaints about.
It just ashed itself as i wrote that last sentence and as you can see the cherry is dead square in the middle and is a little hill, no mountain on this thing.

This cigar is one of the bigger ones i've smoked and it seems to be never ending. I don't think i'm even to the half way point yet... which if you absolutely love this cigar is a good thing. The flavor has gotten a hint of sweetness to it now and a small puff through the nose STINGS!! ouch... yea i got no flavor profile out of that besides too harsh to go through the nose. The sweet has seemed to take over in place for the carmel undertone and still a lot of wood is present with a decent amount of an earthy taste to it.

The burn is starting to become a little uneven in spots but not enough to the point where i need to fix it up yet. The draw is still, the draw i dream of and the taste is only getting sweeter. The sweetness has overtaken the wood flavor and forced it out of the picture. Its now sweetness complimented by undertones of something earthy.

Well after a little longer of smoking this cigar it once again ashed itself a little earlier like it has every time so far. It also got extremely bitter... i mean REALLY bitter. I tried a purge and it helped a little bit, i purged again and it stayed the same... sweet and bitter. I HATE bitter, i hate bitter coffee and i hate bitter cigars. I dunno maybe there was a litter of beetle eggs in that part of the cigar, but either way that was definitely a huge unexpected and unpleasant surprise and to be honest... even if though it was changing my mind about it. Another puff of that much bitterness is not worth the chance of it becoming unbitter again.

My overall thoughts on this cigar seem to be.. mixed opinions. I can see why people would love this cigar. Me personally I'm not a fan of it. The flavors and combo's of flavors just weren't doing it for me. The middle of the cigar was fine and i would buy a cigar that had those flavors and smoked that well. Would i pay top dollar for a cigar like that? No, i'd dish out as much as a typical CAO would run ya.
I feel as though this cigar was playing games with me, like us boys do with girls when we were back in high school. Make you hate us one day then love us the next.

Overall Score of this cigar.
Burn: 8.75
Taste: anywhere from a 0 to 8.5
Ash: 5
Appearance: 6 + 2 for the shinny wrapper it came in

construction: 8
overall: 29 to 39/50.

I did not score this cigar based on my personal opinions and if i liked it or not I.E. the taste, but i based it on how much there was.

Edit: After hitting submit and looking at the pic's, i noticed there seemed to be some white stuff that could be mistaken as mold. I inspected the cigar before lighting and found no mold, what you see in the picture was just ash from my stinky ash tray.

acarr · 11-03-2009, 12:14 AM

Wow thanks for the review. It was about as long as the cigar. I have a box of these and need to dig into soon. If I get the same kind of reaction as you, I might have to sell some of them to someone that does appreciate such a giant cigar!

MedicCook · 11-03-2009, 12:19 AM

I have one sitting in the humi.

kelmac07 · 11-18-2009, 05:50 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MedicCook

I have one sitting in the humi.

Me too!!

shadow king · 11-03-2009, 01:00 AM

Nice review. I've had a few of these bad boys. Both were a few years old. Judging by your pics yours looked fairly new. The ones I had were very mellow. They had a hint of the typical Tat flavor profile. I never experienced the bitterness that you had. Each time I smoked one it took me a good 3 hours to finish it. How long did it take you?

I agree it's a nice cigar if you have a whole afternoon of nothing to do. But I'm not gonna pay the $20 that these usually go for.

cigarmonkel · 11-03-2009, 02:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by shadow king

Nice review. I've had a few of these bad boys. Both were a few years old. Judging by your pics yours looked fairly new. The ones I had were very mellow. They had a hint of the typical Tat flavor profile. I never experienced the bitterness that you had. Each time I smoked one it took me a good 3 hours to finish it. How long did it take you?

I agree it's a nice cigar if you have a whole afternoon of nothing to do. But I'm not gonna pay the $20 that these usually go for.

I didn't finish mine all the way down but i'd say it took me about 1 1/2hrs to get to where i was with it.

I'm not sure how old it was either. I know it was at least 1yr on it, cause i personally have had it for that long. It was also part of a bomb i received so i have no clue how long that person had it for before me. The beginning was extremely mellow then picked up more with the more i smoked it.

11-18-2009, 01:09 AM

Keep hearing alot about these Tats....might have to pick one up and see what all the hype is about.

Excellent review!

Adriftpanda · 11-18-2009, 01:42 AM

I need time to smoke this thing... at least a 2 hour smoke for me. I smoke a little slow.

Sin · 11-18-2009, 03:07 AM

great review and its always a nice bonus when there are pics to drool over!

Don Fernando · 11-18-2009, 03:15 AM

i smoked it's big brother, the 233, last sunday and that was the best smoke I ever had.

roughrider · 11-18-2009, 02:53 PM

Nice pics. Thanks for the review.

secretsquirrel · 12-13-2009, 09:42 AM

Nice review I like a lot of opinion in reviews.

11-02-2009, 11:57 PM	#1
cigarmonkel User Title goes here Join Date: Oct 2008 Location: a2/ypsi. in the mitten Posts: 1,594 Trading: (32)	Tat RC 184 w/ pics as always! So I've moved into a new condo with some buddies who all smoke their own kinda tobaccy. So i started saying well.. im gonna smoke my real tobaccy then in my room. Lit some smell good sticks and opened the window and the smell doesn't reach them. My room is on the ground level, they're on the 3rd floor with the kitchen and living room area on the 2nd floor. Anyways to the point of this thread! I've had this sitting in my vinotemp/humidor for quite sometime now. I was lucky enough to have this from a bomb (not sure who bombed it to me and i deeply apologize!) Appearance: This cigar comes with a shiny silver tin foil wrapping on it (fun for us ADD folk). The wrapper is full of veins, and is surprisingly light. The cap is very nice and has what looks like up to 5 in some spots.. pre-light: It has a very mild smell to it and im hoping this is not a mild cigar. I've done very little research on this cigar so i have no clue what to expect.. hopefully this way i won't have any biased opinions about it. The pre-light draw is very easy and takes very little effect. I'm getting very subtle hints of some sort of wood flavor, and again i'm getting the feeling this is going to be a fairly mild cigar. Initial light: The first puffs taste like nothing but wood, the draw is still extremely easy. the smoke isn't very dense or thick. There are some after flavors which i am having a hard time identifying and are new to me. By now its produced a pretty steady flavor. It has a very smooth earthy flavor, almost reminds me of one of the taboo cigars but cannot remember which one for the life of me. The draw is still very open and easy to grab a lot of smoke. Its also producing a lot more smoke too, not very thick but enough to keep me pleased. This is definitely a more mild smoke. I tend to like my mild smokes earlier in the morning with some coffee and seeing as this stick is a pretty good size probably wouldn't smoke it in the morning. http://i257.photobucket.com/albums/h...Picture073.jpg After about an inch in... this cigar isn't for me. A. its too mild, even if i was to smoke this in the morning it would be too big of a smoke for me in the morning. B. It doesn't seem to wanna hold its flavor as much as i would think from a more rarely seen and smoked cigar.... which maybe is the reason you don't see this being lit up all the time? I'm giving it another chance. Gonna stick with it for a little longer and see how things play out. The taste has picked up more and seems to be... "in the sense" or "more there then not".. if that makes any sense at all. I guess what im trying to say is the flavor is standing out a lot more now. Before i almost felt like i had to sit there, smack my lips a little bit and really search for something. But now its like "Hi my name is flavor". By no means am i saying this cigar has an extreme amount of flavor but compared to when i first lit it... its like a whole new cigar. The flavors i'm getting have gone back to a wood taste with some earthy undertones and a very subtle hint of what seems to be carmel? The burn is staying extremely even which surprises me. The tip you light resembled a fig. roll of a cigar and they never seem to burn evenly for me and i always have to touch it up to get it to burn right. The draw is still perfect in my book. The lighter the draw the better IMO and the smoke is pretty decent. Not as thick as the Illusione MK i had smoked earlier today but still enough to blow smoke rings with and watch it bellow out of your mouth. About 1 inch later this cigar has changed my mind. Good thing i stuck with it (lesson learned). This cigar has completely changed and has gone to a more medium bodied smoke, the flavors seem to just get upfront with every puff i take. the burn is still incredible even and the draw has tightened up just a tad but not nearly enough for me to make any complaints about. It just ashed itself as i wrote that last sentence and as you can see the cherry is dead square in the middle and is a little hill, no mountain on this thing. This cigar is one of the bigger ones i've smoked and it seems to be never ending. I don't think i'm even to the half way point yet... which if you absolutely love this cigar is a good thing. The flavor has gotten a hint of sweetness to it now and a small puff through the nose STINGS!! ouch... yea i got no flavor profile out of that besides too harsh to go through the nose. The sweet has seemed to take over in place for the carmel undertone and still a lot of wood is present with a decent amount of an earthy taste to it. The burn is starting to become a little uneven in spots but not enough to the point where i need to fix it up yet. The draw is still, the draw i dream of and the taste is only getting sweeter. The sweetness has overtaken the wood flavor and forced it out of the picture. Its now sweetness complimented by undertones of something earthy. Well after a little longer of smoking this cigar it once again ashed itself a little earlier like it has every time so far. It also got extremely bitter... i mean REALLY bitter. I tried a purge and it helped a little bit, i purged again and it stayed the same... sweet and bitter. I HATE bitter, i hate bitter coffee and i hate bitter cigars. I dunno maybe there was a litter of beetle eggs in that part of the cigar, but either way that was definitely a huge unexpected and unpleasant surprise and to be honest... even if though it was changing my mind about it. Another puff of that much bitterness is not worth the chance of it becoming unbitter again. My overall thoughts on this cigar seem to be.. mixed opinions. I can see why people would love this cigar. Me personally I'm not a fan of it. The flavors and combo's of flavors just weren't doing it for me. The middle of the cigar was fine and i would buy a cigar that had those flavors and smoked that well. Would i pay top dollar for a cigar like that? No, i'd dish out as much as a typical CAO would run ya. I feel as though this cigar was playing games with me, like us boys do with girls when we were back in high school. Make you hate us one day then love us the next. Overall Score of this cigar. Burn: 8.75 Taste: anywhere from a 0 to 8.5 Ash: 5 Appearance: 6 + 2 for the shinny wrapper it came in construction: 8 overall: 29 to 39/50. I did not score this cigar based on my personal opinions and if i liked it or not I.E. the taste, but i based it on how much there was. Edit: After hitting submit and looking at the pic's, i noticed there seemed to be some white stuff that could be mistaken as mold. I inspected the cigar before lighting and found no mold, what you see in the picture was just ash from my stinky ash tray.

11-03-2009, 12:14 AM	#2
acarr Have My Own Room Join Date: Oct 2008 Posts: 1,307 Trading: (34)	Re: Tat RC 184 w/ pics as always! Wow thanks for the review. It was about as long as the cigar. I have a box of these and need to dig into soon. If I get the same kind of reaction as you, I might have to sell some of them to someone that does appreciate such a giant cigar!

11-03-2009, 12:19 AM	#3
MedicCook Mila smoked my cigar Join Date: Jan 2009 First Name: Ryan Location: Schaghticoke, NY Posts: 10,946 Trading: (7)	Re: Tat RC 184 w/ pics as always! I have one sitting in the humi. __________________ 27 World Series Championship's "If your wife doesn't like the aroma of your cigar, change your wife.", Zino Davidoff

11-03-2009, 01:00 AM	#5
shadow king Fresh outta Ad Seg Join Date: Mar 2009 First Name: Matt Location: Last house on the left Posts: 466 Trading: (19)	Re: Tat RC 184 w/ pics as always! Nice review. I've had a few of these bad boys. Both were a few years old. Judging by your pics yours looked fairly new. The ones I had were very mellow. They had a hint of the typical Tat flavor profile. I never experienced the bitterness that you had. Each time I smoked one it took me a good 3 hours to finish it. How long did it take you? I agree it's a nice cigar if you have a whole afternoon of nothing to do. But I'm not gonna pay the $20 that these usually go for.

11-18-2009, 01:09 AM	#7
Namerifrats Guest Posts: n/a	Re: Tat RC 184 w/ pics as always! Keep hearing alot about these Tats....might have to pick one up and see what all the hype is about. Excellent review!

11-18-2009, 01:42 AM	#8
Adriftpanda Peter's Daddy Join Date: May 2009 First Name: Huy Location: No one wants me Posts: 10,313 Trading: (74)	Re: Tat RC 184 w/ pics as always! I need time to smoke this thing... at least a 2 hour smoke for me. I smoke a little slow. __________________ Who eats plantains when they can eat placenta.

11-18-2009, 03:07 AM	#9
Sin Huskin Corn & smkin cgars Join Date: Oct 2009 First Name: Pete Location: Husker Nation Posts: 44 Trading: (0)	Re: Tat RC 184 w/ pics as always! great review and its always a nice bonus when there are pics to drool over!

11-18-2009, 03:15 AM	#10
Don Fernando Postwhore Join Date: Oct 2008 First Name: Ferdinand Location: Singapore Posts: 10,070 Trading: (29)	Re: Tat RC 184 w/ pics as always! i smoked it's big brother, the 233, last sunday and that was the best smoke I ever had. __________________ check out my reviews on my blog.

11-18-2009, 02:53 PM	#11
roughrider Feeling at Home Join Date: Oct 2008 Location: SF Bay Area Posts: 835 Trading: (24)	Re: Tat RC 184 w/ pics as always! Nice pics. Thanks for the review.

12-13-2009, 09:42 AM	#12
secretsquirrel Yeah so Join Date: Nov 2009 First Name: m Location: S.E. Indiana Posts: 128 Trading: (12)	Re: Tat RC 184 w/ pics as always! Nice review I like a lot of opinion in reviews.