We are planning on Riviera Maya for the winter holidays for a belated honeymoon, have to do some serious number crunching though. Can't wait.
Perception: No preconceptions, going open minded.
Vacation: Absolutely, see above.
Safety: As long as we are in the places we are supposed to be in no worries at all.
Pluses: Money goes further, shorter flights, less weather worries - hurricanes, etc.
Minuses: Ask we when we get back.