What they smoked:
2002 Fonseca Cosaco
jimmyk26 score: 7.5
Brutus2600 score: 8.25
These things were not expensive at all, but man... I dig em.
Nice mellow stick, great thing for the morning w/ coffee.
Here's a hint for you guys, though. When it starts getting that bitter taste near the end, purge it (meaning blow out through the cigar, forcing the air through the lit end). I do this CONSTANTLY while smoking my cigars and it just keeps them good the whole way through.
Another thing is that if I want the cigar to be the main focus (instead of getting lost in the beverage as was described above) I pair with Pellegrino Sparkling Water (something I learned from a really smart guy at Shack last year). Try it if you'd like... it's the perfect compliment to a good cigar.
Great reviews, guys... I really love the detail!