Dude - I'm all over this!
I have historically broke my reviews down into four parts:
Construction
Initial Flavors
Continuing Flavors
With Whisky
Here are some of my past reviews:
H Upmann Mag 48 EL 2009
Kensington Chateau maduro
Liga Privada T52
601 Red Habano
Fuente Magnum R
One of the main reasons I smoke cigars is to enjoy the experience of trying new ones. My "inventory" is comprised of a lot of singles and five packs so I can try a whole range of cigars - the variation in flavors is a major benefit! The same goes for single malt scotch, rum, wine, etc.
I've enjoyed scotch for a much longer period than I have cigars - but teasing out the flavors in scotch has helped with pulling out notes in cigars.
So far, I'd estimate that I've been smoking for about 6 months, so am still relatively new.
I've wanted to try one of these blind taste tests, but haven't been able to get into one yet.
Would be very happy to try!