Thanks everyone. Reading through this thread I've just come to realize that every Padron that I've enjoyed smoking never sat in my humidor for a long period of time. The ones that aged year or two of age either made me sick or left me very disappointed (for the price).
I will also note that anything over $15 I really start wonder about the value. It's seem to be my personal price point when I expect a cigar to knock my socks off.
I've decided that once I've kicked this head cold, I'm putting a flame to this cigar. Should I report back here or is there another area I should post my experience?
WARNING: SHAMELESS PLUG

---------------------------------------
As on of the co-founders of Free Cigar Ratings, I will be putting my review up our site. But I will also share my finding with the new friends that I've found here.