I tried my first this past sunday as well, I got the coffee and cocoa flavors, just a hint of pepper, I was really surprised at this stick, Good construction, kinda a light sheen to it, not dry looking. The stick i smoked was the churchill, i believe, and I got mine in a trade with Andy himself!
I have several more but im gonna let them sit a couple weeks to see if the flavors change any!
All in all, yes I would definately buy this !
I think Andy may be on to something here.IMHO!
Leroy