I know this topic pops up from time to time but after last nights suprise I couldn't resist posting up.
My third cigar of the evening was a Maria Mancini which I have had resting for about 3 years now. Nice dark wrapper... blah blah blah.... to the point-
I clipped the cap and the cutter did not separate from the cigar? I was thinking WTF? As I force the two apart I see something white? (Sorry the pictures are bad, they were taken with a camera phone)

Oh yeah, this is weird shite. I pull the end that is sticking outside of the cigar and out comes a nugget of rolled up paper towel.
After further discussion we came to the conclusion that it was probably a dingle-berry.
I smoked the cigar anyway and it was great.
What kind of garbage have you found inside your cigars?