A buddy of mine was on the hunt for pork tenderloins and found them at Cigar Thief. He texted me the link asking if the site was legit or not... It apparently looked sus to him.
A cursory search here and on Reddit brought nothing alarming. So I told him to go for it.
Searching on there I found Sunday Gravy in stock. So I said, why not.
Order was communicated thoroughly at each step. Shipping was USPS from PA and arrived in Houston in 3 days from ordering. All in all, very impressed.
He also ordered some Diesel Crucibles (which were in stock in his cart) but apparently before processing the sale, the box was sold and didn't notify him.
They immediately sent him an email apologizing for the error and offered him a refund or a store credit plus 15% off his next order.
His other smokes arrived just as quickly as mine.
I'd say they're a keeper.