Sounds like a great night, Ben. I've only ever had the 4 year Willett, I am guessing it's just escalating goodness.
Any chance one of the Old Carters was American Batch 4 (139.6 proof)? I still haven't cracked mine, and they're already going for double what I paid for it a few months ago.
Brian, please get a picture of the bourbon list from Newbury Bros. when you go inside. Love to see it.
__________________
Thanks Dave, Julian, James, Kelly, Peter, Gerry, Dave, Mo, Frank, Týr and Mr. Mark!