While in NYC a couple of weeks ago I bench marked these two place in preparation of opening my own. Worth a visit for sure. Cigar Inn carries no booze but a liquor store is two doors away.
http://www.circatabac.com/
32 Watts St.
New York, NY 10013
info@circatabac.com
212-941-1781
http://www.cigarinn.com/catalog/02_about.htm
1016 Second Avenue
(Between 53rd & 54th)
NY, NY 10022
212-750-0809