I agree that there is a trendiness to cigars. Your point is well taken that my top 10 list would just be unique to myself and I'm sure many would like a few cigars on my list and might even agree that one of mine made their top 10.
I've read a lot of top 10 lists from bloggers to CA and only 1 or two even got picked twice.
I prefer to look at these lists as guides to cigars to try. My cigar ADD forces me to try new things so I'll check out a list or two for ideas. On that note, I've a box of Ortega Serie D Maduros on there way!!! Hoo yaa!
Oh, and Cuba Aliados Miami's are good cigars so leave them for me biatches!!!