Sounds like you should take a dive into the Maduro variants of the smokes you like. The Padron maduros are wonderful smokes, and so is the Camacho Triple Maduro. Dont be afraid of that one, just enjoy it after a full meal. The triple maduros I have smoked have been medium-full but not buttkicking nicotine bombs.
Also, the EP Carillo lines are full flavored and full bodied, but have some great flavors to them and are certainly worth a try.
If money is an issue, many of the smokes listed can be found on the devil site in 5ers, or they can be ordered online cheap and sometimes without tax.
If you keep going the way you are, you will soon have whole new worlds of cigar enjoyment to confront!