Not so sure I agree with this year, but haven't tried a Casa Magna yet.
2007 was interesting as well, although a good arguement can be made for the Padron 1926 No 9 as well as the Montecristo #2.
How the heck did the Opus Perfecxion 2 get in there though??? Put the Cohiba maduro 5 in there instead of in 6th place and it is pretty solid for me...
I heard Rod Blagojevich had something to do with the Casa Magna spot this year but need to research further...
http://www.cigaraficionado.com/Cigar...0,2007,00.html