Nothing will compare to a legit Cuban Cohiba, assuming that is what you had. And no one here can make accurate recommendations on what you will like based on the fact you have one cigar to compare your tastes to. Its like asking us to pick the best beer to drink based on the fact that you like Bud Select.
Like others have said, go to the New Inmate Forum and introduce yourself, then spend some time reading the stickies and learning.
