[srduggins]

I bought the sampler two years ago and much preferred the #4, although I generally like a smaller ring gauge. Well worth the coin, but I never seemed to buy any more. I remember being surprised by how much worse one of them was, perhaps I got two bad sticks. To answer your question, I think I liked the #1 better than the #2, but it's been a while, so I'd just get the sampler and try them for myself (again).