Had another tasting tonight with some friends. Imperial Stouts was the theme, but some porters made it in as well.
2009 Abyss
2009 Jolly Pumpkin Dark Dawn Stout
Some Irish Stout I can't remember
2010 Night Tripper
2011 Plead The Fifth
2011 Karl Strauss Parrot In A Palm Tree
2010 Black Xantus
2011 Belgo Anise RIS from Stone
2010 Chocolate Yeti
2011 Dark Lord
2010 Founders Breakfast Stout
2011 Founders Breakfast Stout
2011 Founders Imperial Stout
2011 Founders KBS
Also, a couple homebrews didn't make the picture.
Tonights winners, IMO, Black Xantus, Dark Lord, and KBS. Overall, I enjoyed every beer.