[Ashcan Bill]

We just returned on the Carnival Splendor and I couldn't have been happier. Instead of a small, cramped "lounge" where cigarette and cigar smokes are crammed in on top of each other, the cigar bar was spacious. Plenty of room for everyone, with live entertainment to boot.

This is the first cruise ship I've seen that provided a decent indoor space for smokers. I just booked us again on the same ship next year. The cruise line that treats me like a human being gets my $$.