I had this same thing happen with a Benni Jorgensen Swan pipe around Christmas time. So, I got a picture of the pipe & sent it to Stephen Downie... and if you all saw the thread I made a few weeks back, you've seen the result.
Don't be disheartened, Tyler. The one that got away CAN be "got back." But whether or not that pipe will still be as appealing to the wallet, that cannot be guaranteed.