Our opinions just differ on this I guess....and that is 100% okay.  There is no right and wrong here.  
Though it is nice to give an experienced cigar smoker a nice cigar, I get as much pleasure giving a great cigar to someone just dipping their feet in this ocean....  
Too many people have no idea what a good cigar tastes like....  I'd like to change that and can, one person at a time....
