All I do these days is check this site, because I've been around long enough that I know whose tastes on this site are similar enough to mine that I can trust a review. If I need encyclopedic information I'll check the
CC Website and for fun I follow
Brook's and
Brad's blogs more for their skills as quality bloggers/ cigar photographers and writers than any "objective review" that I've yet to find.
The best bet is to read a few reviews of cigars you know well from each blog you know of and find somebody that has a similar pallate and tastes as you, otherwise, all the reviews in world are basically worthless