What Punch had the best flavor profile for you?
 

I haven't had a Punch cigar for years and can't remember the profile, what one out of these major offering is your favorite?
And the size that was best also?
Thanks! :tu

Punch
Punch Bareknuckle
Punch Deluxe
Punch Gran Cru
Punch Gran Puro
Punch Rare Corojo
Punch Rare Corojo 10th Anniversary
Punch Uppercut

Re: What Punch had the best flavor profile for you?
 

IMVHO,
Punch - boring as heck
Punch Bareknuckle - awful
Punch Deluxe - nh
Punch Gran Cru - had, but so memorable I remember nothing about it
Punch Gran Puro - did nothing for me
Punch Rare Corojo - only NC Punch I ever wanted more than once - esp in the little perfecto
Punch Rare Corojo 10th Anniversary - nh
Punch Uppercut -worse than the Bareknuckle

Re: What Punch had the best flavor profile for you?
 

I personally enjoy the Punch Punch. :2

Re: What Punch had the best flavor profile for you?
 

Wow fast response, that's a concise observation, maybe why I never picked one up again.:D
Thanks brother :tu

Re: What Punch had the best flavor profile for you?
 

This. Best one ever. ;)

Re: What Punch had the best flavor profile for you?
 

Black Prince myself....Ninfas arent bad either!

Re: What Punch had the best flavor profile for you?
 

Punch is one line that I've had zero luck with.

Re: What Punch had the best flavor profile for you?
 

Punch Punch, although it's been years since I had one
Rare Corojo
Bareknuckle, although it needs some rest

Re: What Punch had the best flavor profile for you?
 

I would agree with this. Taken quite a few shots at it too, as occasionally I would think I was overlooking them, or that they couldn't all be that meh. But trying another one would always end the same.

Einstein's definition of insanity - doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results. So yeah, I don't try Punch anymore. :D

Re: What Punch had the best flavor profile for you?
 

Must be why I haven't tried one for years :rolleyes:
Thanks

Re: What Punch had the best flavor profile for you?
 

I've always liked the Punch Rare Corojo in the rothschild size. Even though they are not rare and do not contain any Corojo.

Re: What Punch had the best flavor profile for you?
 

I remember enjoying the Gran Puro and Rare Corojo both.

Re: What Punch had the best flavor profile for you?
 

Superfino. Best. RE. Ever.

Re: What Punch had the best flavor profile for you?
 

No, they are not. :dr

I agree, wish they had made more.

Adding:

Punch Descobridores RE
Punch Petite Punch

and

Punch Necatres for the win

Re: What Punch had the best flavor profile for you?
 

When I was a noob I remember the Punch Gran Cru to be an o.k. maduro.

Notice. OK.

The Rare Corojo and 1oth Anni Corojo are quite nice and pretty easy to get your hands on.

Re: What Punch had the best flavor profile for you?
 

NC speaking, I enjoy the Gran Puro.
One of the few cigars that really pairs well with tequila.

Rare Crojo is pretty nice, too.

Re: What Punch had the best flavor profile for you?
 

ss#1

derrek

Re: What Punch had the best flavor profile for you?
 

Only One I Like Is The Gran Puro. Great Cigar, IMO.:2:tu

Re: What Punch had the best flavor profile for you?
 

I see Punch getting a lot of "meh" reviews, with the word "boring" coming up quite often. I used to grab standard Punch Robustos I suppose because they were familiar, easy to find, and weren't bad. I'm curious to have another go at them now that I feel like I may have a (somewhat) more discerning palette.

That's the great thing about this hobby. There's never a shortage of new things to try, and the deeper you go, revisiting old smokes can be a new experience.

Re: What Punch had the best flavor profile for you?
 

Ninfas. Aged Punch is also one of my faves.