Which would you buy?
 

So I'm currently going to order a 5 capacity herfidor, and want to order a 5 pack of cigars too. I think I've narrowed it down to CAO Brazilia Gol or Diesel Unholy Cocktail. Ordering from CI. Unless you guys recommend a better place.

Re: Which would you buy?
 

buy both and a mix and match!

Re: Which would you buy?
 

lol. I actually just saw they have a herf-n-go pack for $35. There is a dominican sampler that includes:

Herfidor - 5 capacity

Macanudo Hyde park
Cohiba Red Dot
LGC Wavell
Partagas naturales
Partagas black classico

Oh, and it comes with a cutter and lighter too. And free shipping!

Re: Which would you buy?
 

So, that and 1 more 5 pack... hmmm..... I really like the Brazilia gol, but haven't had the diesel.

Re: Which would you buy?
 

i just smoked a diesel earlier today. I'm not a fan of maddies but THAT was DELICIOUS!

Re: Which would you buy?
 

is there someone local who will do a mix and match split with you?

Re: Which would you buy?
 

Nope. I'm in the middle of nowhere. northern MN.

Re: Which would you buy?
 

I prefer the diesel over the brazila

Re: Which would you buy?
 

A huge +1 on the diesel.

Re: Which would you buy?
 

damnit. I bought the brazilia because i've had it and like it. going to a music festival in a week, and wanted to be sure I.m liking what i smoke. Oh well. Maybe next time. At least i know the diesel should be good.

Re: Which would you buy?
 

I love the hell out of CAO's Brazilia. Easily one of my top 5 favorite cigars I have smoked. I think it was a wise choice.

Re: Which would you buy?
 

If you like the Brazilias then go for it. It's all about what you like not what we like.

Try the diesels later.

Re: Which would you buy?
 

I've had both, Diesel's good but like the CAO better. It's all personal taste.

Re: Which would you buy?
 

I have had them both, and I would have to say that they are easily two of my favorites. You didn't choose wrong, but either way would have worked.

Re: Which would you buy?
 

They are both great cigars.

Re: Which would you buy?
 

I currently have and smoke both of them. Great cigars, cant go wrong with either one.

Re: Which would you buy?
 

Brazilia has a great flavor profile, and CAO rolls pretty consistent sticks.

Re: Which would you buy?
 

I recommend a much larger Herf-a-dor! :)

Re: Which would you buy?
 

:tpd:

Re: Which would you buy?
 

two entirely diffrent cigars, especially the wrappers si its like comparing apples tp oranges. I have smoked both and they both really good cigars the diesel being more medium and the Brazilia leans towards full. Do love that pennsylvania broadleaf on the Diesel thou.