Cigars with mineral/soil notes?
 

Hey all!

So I'm getting close to rounding up most of the cigars I need (NEED I say! Not want!) for vacation in June. I have lots of great corojos, chocolately maduros, CCs, and so on. I feel like I have most of my bases covered, except for one I've been interested in.
I know most often the mineral/soil/dirt notes a lot of people mention in their reviews play second fiddle to more predominate notes like pepper, cedar, coffee, etc. What I'm wondering is if there are any cigars/blends that really showcase the more earthy/mineraly notes I mentioned? I've googled and searched for such, but often just brings up results about the soil the tobacco is grown in, haha.
So I figure who better to ask than all of you? Can any of you recommend any cigars that have a lot of those kinds of notes? Preferably full or medium-full bodied cigars but open to any kind of wrapper! So far really the only one I could think of would maybe be My Father Le Bijou.
A big thanks in advance for any and all recommendations!! -(P

Re: Cigars with mineral/soil notes?
 

I personally get a mineral taste from Dominican cigars. So, that would point to Fuente, La Aurora, LFD...

Re: Cigars with mineral/soil notes?
 

Thanks Bob! Good to hear, I have a couple 5ers of LFD in the humidor right now and as for Fuente, I already have an Eye if the Shark Sampler ready and waiting specifically for the vacation. :tu
Will look more in to La Aurora though!!

Re: Cigars with mineral/soil notes?
 

I’ve never really understood earthy flavors and mineral is generally not good for my palate. That being said, Tatauaje Fausto or Avion. Fantastic cigar and reviewers find earth but I call it “rich tobacco” since I don’t eat dirt.

Re: Cigars with mineral/soil notes?
 

Small Batch Cigar actually has some recommendations on different flavor profiles in cigars. They have a few different posts of how to hone your palate with selections for each major type of flavor described in cigars. I'm not sure if I can link to their blog here since they are also a retailer? [If a Mod reads this then please let me know one way or the other.]

But this is their selection for earth which is what I think you are describing.

DEVELOP YOUR PALATE – EARTH | CALDWELL ALL OUT KINGS
Earth comes in many shapes and sizes but is unmistakable in just about any cigar in the Liga Privada series. To broaden our horizons, we selected the All Out Kings collaboration between Robert Caldwell, Willie Herrera, and Jonathan Drew. This cigar features the Liga Privada T-52 wrapper and is the perfect introduction to an earthy cigar.

Of course, earth is such a broad term that once you discover it you’ll be hard-pressed to just call it earth afterward. There’s dry dirt, wet soil, clay, damp (dank) earth, etc. And different cigars will project different nuances of earth over the course of the experience. Once lit, All Out Kings will initiate you into earthy tasting notes with what Andrew calls, “sweaty earth.”

Re: Cigars with mineral/soil notes?
 

:r

@ Wallbright that sounds like just what I need, a resource to look for cigars by flavor profiles, will be checking out Small batch for sure. I've stumbled across their site once or twice before but didn't really look under the hood, so to speak.
And All out Kings is going on the research list along with La Aurora! Thanks guys, this will definitely get me started!

Re: Cigars with mineral/soil notes?
 

Puros Indios = Spicy dirt.

Re: Cigars with mineral/soil notes?
 

Only after hour 4 :r

https://www.cgarsltd.co.uk/images/Pu...-the-chief.jpg

Re: Cigars with mineral/soil notes?
 

Re: Cigars with mineral/soil notes?
 

Haha that is crazy! Will add those to the list as well, but maybe a slightly smaller size...

Re: Cigars with mineral/soil notes?
 

I could be wrong, but I think he was making a joke saying Puros Indios don't taste good. They are infamous for not being very good.

Re: Cigars with mineral/soil notes?
 

Yeeeeah you might be on to something, the reviews were less than stellar from what I was seeing...thanks for a confirmation though. :)

Re: Cigars with mineral/soil notes?
 

Since Liga Privada has been mentioned, you should also look into the Dunbarton Tobacco lines, Sobremesa, Mi Querida, Umbagog, etc. Steve Saka who was behind the LP’s now owns/runs DTT. Some similar profiles.

Re: Cigars with mineral/soil notes?
 

Excellent! Yeah most of those were already in the "maybe" column for vacation, but thinking they've now been nudged to "definite 5ers". :D

Re: Cigars with mineral/soil notes?
 

I haven't had one in ages but from what I remember gurkha's we're predominantly wet soil Earth and dirt notes. Honestly one of the things that steers people away from them but if that's your thing I'd give it a go. More specifically it was the Gurkha Shaggy :tf

Re: Cigars with mineral/soil notes?
 

Carlos Torano used to have the taste of dirt. Nothing as fancy as "soil". :D Not sure if they're still like that, I haven't smoked one for at least 15 years, 'cause I hate 'em. :r

Re: Cigars with mineral/soil notes?
 

Yeah Gurkha is one of the brands I tend to avoid too, but might take a look at Torano! It seems it might be a note that a lot of people avoid, but I had a cigar a while back that had a few fleeting notes of what I could only describe as fresh, mineraly soil. But in a good way! Sort of like the smell of the earth/mud outside after a nice fresh rain.
Only problem is that I can't remember for sure which cigar it was! I wanted to say it was the Le Bijou but I very well could be confusing it with something else, haha.
The Saka stuff sounds promising along with the All Out Kings, also plan to check out the stuff Weelok suggested too.
Thanks again everyone for the suggestions, you've all been really helpful! :tu

Re: Cigars with mineral/soil notes?
 

It you end up liking those Torano dirt notes, your palate is definitely different than mine.

I've had several of the Saka cigars, and those are very tasty, albeit a little pricey at times.

Re: Cigars with mineral/soil notes?
 

That last bit made me laugh out loud for real haha

Re: Cigars with mineral/soil notes?
 

Most people 'round these parts will tell ya that's what I'm here for. -(P :D

Re: Cigars with mineral/soil notes?
 

Maybe it’s me but I rather not taste dirt when I’m smoking a cigar.

However, just try try try. Whatever you can get your hands on.

Re: Cigars with mineral/soil notes?
 

Older Sancho Panza cigars had a mineral taste and you could even see mineral traces on the wrapper. Unique cigar, but the most recent ones lost some of that taste.

Re: Cigars with mineral/soil notes?
 

Yeah that sounds much more like what I think I'm looking for....too bad it sounds like the new ones haven't retained that unique character though.

Re: Cigars with mineral/soil notes?
 

SP Belicoso's are worth picking up. Some may taste a little saltier than others. Fun cigar either way and don't break the bank.

Re: Cigars with mineral/soil notes?
 

Thanks for the recommendation! I'll be sure to keep an eye out for the Belicosos, i just looked them up and I like what I've read so far! :tu

Re: Cigars with mineral/soil notes?
 

If by mineral you mean metallic you could try La Unica.