Has Gurkha redeemed themselves?
 

Everyone who knows me is familiar with my low opinion of Gurkhas. Everyone I tried except for the Vintage Shaggy, was a disappointment. The Elegance was okay, very mild with little excitement. But, Donny from the Cigar Room in Madison, AL encouraged me to try the Seduction. He was so sure I'd like it, he gave me one. I actually liked it well enough to buy some yesterday from Ken Mansfield who was at the CR for an event. I found the Seduction a medium to full body smoke but I need to concentrate more on the next one so I can give a more reliable review but it never had that initial funk that most Gurkhas I've smoked had.

The 15 year cellar reserve was also a surprisingly good stick. It did start out with that familiar Gurkha wang which I care little for, once you get past that in the first 5 minutes, it develops into quite a remarkable stick. I would envision the shorter ones not being that great since you'd have to get past that initial raunch. I would definitely consider these in future buys.:tu

Re: Has Gurkha redeemed themselves?
 

I had a couple of the Ninja line,they were really quite good.

Re: Has Gurkha redeemed themselves?
 

Gurkha wang........

http://i196.photobucket.com/albums/a...g3/homerdr.jpg

Re: Has Gurkha redeemed themselves?
 

I vowed to never try another one but may have to give it a go:/

Re: Has Gurkha redeemed themselves?
 

Now I know where to send all my Gurkhas. :tu :r

Re: Has Gurkha redeemed themselves?
 

They sort of jumped the shark for me with some of the hype/marketing tall tales and gimmicks. I don't need my cigars to come in a cheesy treasure chest box, just focus on blending the tobaccky would ya?

Re: Has Gurkha redeemed themselves?
 

The problem I have with Gurkha is they are inconstant. I have had a few that were good, bought more from the same box and tossed them after the first inch. I dont want to waste my money on a gamble of that nature.

Re: Has Gurkha redeemed themselves?
 

^ This. Some are rolled so tight you can't even keep 'em lit!

Re: Has Gurkha redeemed themselves?
 

Even if Gurkha does a better job don't worry...

Rocky is doing his best to catch up to Gurkha in the "release a crap-mediocre blend every month" race.

Re: Has Gurkha redeemed themselves?
 

Maybe he pranked you by swapping bands. :D

Re: Has Gurkha redeemed themselves?
 

I have to agree I also surprisingly enjoyed the cellar reserve I had the koi size. It tasted like a good cigar smells.

Re: Has Gurkha redeemed themselves?
 

Also have to agree with islayphile very true.

Re: Has Gurkha redeemed themselves?
 

gurkha ??? come on !!! you can not be serious..

There are many better brands out there in the market.
For instance ; CAO is my favorite brand of all times.

Re: Has Gurkha redeemed themselves?
 

I think it all falls back to the mantra "Smoke what you like, like what you smoke"

Re: Has Gurkha redeemed themselves?
 

I've only tried one from the gurhka line it was enough for me to say no thanks on the next one....

Re: Has Gurkha redeemed themselves?
 

I tried a few Gurkhas, didn't like any of them.
Bad cigars + poor try hard marketing = I prolly would never try another one.

If you like them smoke them, there should be plenty left for you.
There are only two things that could survive a Lars Tetans nuclear meltdown;
A cockroach and a cockroach infused Gurkha.


I am in a pissy mood this morning, I need to get ofline for a bit.
Sorry for my whining this morning.

Re: Has Gurkha redeemed themselves?
 

+1 :lr I hear ya brother....getting out of hand!!

Dont think I will try another Gurkha ever, I love when they say it retails for $1,000,000,000. (slight exaggeration of course) and then they sell it for $2.00 :lr

Re: Has Gurkha redeemed themselves?
 

It's a strange concept to me...

If they keep releasing crap blends over and over again, eventually folks like me, you and many others will never bother trying out any of their new offerings after we've been let down by their previous releases.

I don't think there are enough new cigar smokers out there to keep that business model going.

Re: Has Gurkha redeemed themselves?
 

They excel at losing customers, but they're obviously even better at creating new ones, they remain in business despite driving guys off with their cigars.
They're definitely advertising 101. They have their name and pictures in all the cigar magazines, they're almost impossible to avoid. I suppose they're as good an "introduction to cigars" brand as so many others.
The nice thing about them is that they're almost free at cbid. The bad thing about them is that most aren't even worth that.

Re: Has Gurkha redeemed themselves?
 

All very true

My question is how long can they continue to do that and still remain successful?

Re: Has Gurkha redeemed themselves?
 

I used to like Gurkha (Centurian and Black Dragon) when I first started smoking- the only problem was the wrappers always seemed to split.

Re: Has Gurkha redeemed themselves?
 

I tried a few ghurkas and I liked them all so far

Re: Has Gurkha redeemed themselves?
 

Different strokes for different folks. CAO is on my crap list for some truly horrendous smokes. I've had a few good Gurk's but not a single good CAO. Everyones taste is a little different. :2

Re: Has Gurkha redeemed themselves?
 

Maybe they've finally seen the light and have tried a bit harder to make a better stick. I had completely written them off except for the Vintage Shaggy. It took a free cigar to even get me to look at them again. It looks like they spend too much on fancy packaging instead of paying attention to the actual taste.

Re: Has Gurkha redeemed themselves?
 

Jake a lot of guys here locally LOVE the cellar reserve! One of my buddy's loves the KOI! He says it packs the most punch and has great flavors to boo! I still haven't had the resolve to try one myself, but the next time i see them I may just grab one.

Re: Has Gurkha redeemed themselves?
 

I went through a whole box of G3s without any problem. A very tasty and distinctive smoke. I still have the last one and I will try a recent one from a B&M and if it is still good I will buy another box. I have not liked any other Gurkha enough to buy another one.

Re: Has Gurkha redeemed themselves?
 

As a Noob, take my opinion with a grain of salt. But, I have tried 4 different Gurkhas with the G3 being the only one I would smoke again if someone gave it to me.

Re: Has Gurkha redeemed themselves?
 

I have a Cellar Reserve in the humi. I have had a few Gurkha's and have not been real impressed.