Cigar Asylum Cigar Forum - Cigar Aficionado's new rating system!!!

Cigar Asylum Cigar Forum (http://www.cigarasylum.com/vb/index.php)

- All Cigar Discussion (http://www.cigarasylum.com/vb/forumdisplay.php?f=5)

- - Cigar Aficionado's new rating system!!! (http://www.cigarasylum.com/vb/showthread.php?t=3302)

Cigar Aficionado's new rating system!!!

Re: Cigar Aficionado's new rating system!!!

Very funny. Although I can't agree with them about the cigar.

Re: Cigar Aficionado's new rating system!!!

:r:r Nice! That is pretty funny!

Re: Cigar Aficionado's new rating system!!!

An over rated cigar gets a good review..... What has changed?:D

Re: Cigar Aficionado's new rating system!!!

:r

Nice one Mikey. Give me a call this weekend, let's have a smoke. :tu

Re: Cigar Aficionado's new rating system!!!

19 bucks for one of those??!?!?!!?

Re: Cigar Aficionado's new rating system!!!

I wanna try one of these, but I'm certainly not going $19 for an unproven cigar. Hmmmmm. Dilemna here.

Re: Cigar Aficionado's new rating system!!!

CAO? then it's not worth $19 for the box!

Re: Cigar Aficionado's new rating system!!!

How that was their #9 cigar of 2007 still perplexes me. :hm

Re: Cigar Aficionado's new rating system!!!

Quote:

Originally Posted by silentjon (Post 50083)

How that was their #9 cigar of 2007 still perplexes me. :hm

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ :hm

Re: Cigar Aficionado's new rating system!!!

I'd love to see the other ratings!! Is "not fit for your dog" one?

:r :r :r

Re: Cigar Aficionado's new rating system!!!

Quote:

Originally Posted by Don Fernando (Post 50038)

CAO? then it's not worth $19 for the box!

:tpd: 'nuff said

Re: Cigar Aficionado's new rating system!!!

Talking about the box or the cigar?

The box IS really nice....

Re: Cigar Aficionado's new rating system!!!

that is funny as hell I was all excited to see that they were gonna maybe start to review stuff better but that is really funny.

Re: Cigar Aficionado's new rating system!!!

Quote:

Originally Posted by RX2010 (Post 49981)

19 bucks for one of those??!?!?!!?

Welcome to California.

Re: Cigar Aficionado's new rating system!!!

I sure do love those Vision boxes!

Re: Cigar Aficionado's new rating system!!!

Quote:

Originally Posted by Darrell (Post 52022)

Welcome to California.

:tpd:

Re: Cigar Aficionado's new rating system!!!

Quote:

Originally Posted by groogs (Post 49954)

An over rated cigar gets a good review..... What has changed?:D

:r :r :r Well said... :D

Re: Cigar Aficionado's new rating system!!!

Quote:

Originally Posted by dcamacho (Post 50125)

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ :hm

I do not think they would harm the integrity of their magazine just for advertising revenue. ;)

Re: Cigar Aficionado's new rating system!!!

Quote:

Originally Posted by Don Fernando (Post 50038)

CAO? then it's not worth $19 for the box!

Actually it is. Just not the cigars in it.

Re: Cigar Aficionado's new rating system!!!

Quote:

Originally Posted by Misha (Post 52261)

Actually it is. Just not the cigars in it.

True, the box would be a fun addition to a collection, I just don't think the cigars would wow me.

Re: Cigar Aficionado's new rating system!!!

Quote:

Originally Posted by SmokeyNL (Post 52272)

True, the box would be a fun addition to a collection, I just don't think the cigars would wow me.

I keep tying to like this cigar, but I just can't. The box is pretty cool though.

Re: Cigar Aficionado's new rating system!!!

This must be a west coast review, "slap your mom good!" Pleaze...

ITs " Slap yo' Momma good"

No comment on the CAO brand,I'm just trying to maintain a little integrity in the reviews around here.. :D

Re: Cigar Aficionado's new rating system!!!

With so many cigars on the market, presentation and marketing can be everything even though the cigar may not worthy.

Examples:

Look at the marketing and presentation of the Partagas 150's.
Look at the marketing and presentation of the Opus X
Look at the marketing and presentation of the CAO Vision

Not a knock on any of those cigars mind you but the presentation alone can make an everyday consumer choose one of the above over more plain-jane type presentations when on the shelf among thousands of other boxes of cigars.

Re: Cigar Aficionado's new rating system!!!

this just in.... CAO cigars are Master P appoved!!!

http://a745.ac-images.myspacecdn.com...27377744_l.jpg

UUUGGGGHHHHHH!!!!