Just One Cigar
 

If you could only smoke one cigar for the rest of your life, what would you choose and why?

I think for me, I'd have to say the 601 Black, I love everything about this cigar and could smoke it morning, noon or night.

Re: Just One Cigar
 

T110.

'nuff said, IMHO.

Re: Just One Cigar
 

Cohiba Esplendido with five or more years in the humi.

Re: Just One Cigar
 

Cohiba Siglo II.

Re: Just One Cigar
 

:tpd: Thought about this as soon as i read the topic..

Re: Just One Cigar
 

cohiba siglo VIs; beautiful cigar.

Re: Just One Cigar
 

I'm glad someone else thinks the 601 black labels are as tasty as I do!

but as far as picking one cigar for all time?

jeez... I really can't think of one. I mean, I love a good steak, but it would get old pretty quick if that's the only thing I had to eat for every meal. :(

Re: Just One Cigar
 

I typed something similar earlier but didn't hit "submit". I don't know if I would smoke a fraction of what I smoke now if this were the case.

Re: Just One Cigar
 

I would choose the Gurkha black dragon because it would make me quit smokin.

Re: Just One Cigar
 

Davidoff Château Latour or Château Mouton Rothschild

if you gotta be limited, be limited in a big way :tu

Re: Just One Cigar
 

Illusione HL

Can't stop buying them.

Re: Just One Cigar
 

swisher sweet!


















































JK:td

Re: Just One Cigar
 

I know it's a rather silly question in reality. Truth is, what I was smoking last year at this time isn't what I'm smoking now and the same will likely be true this time next year. But a fun question nonetheless. Plus I'm discovering some new cigars this way.

Re: Just One Cigar
 

This changes all the time for me, but right now I'm really liking the AJF Diesel. I could stay with these a long time.

Re: Just One Cigar
 

Liga Privada No. 9

Probably not a big surprise considering my avatar...

Re: Just One Cigar
 

This was almost my response. There's no reason to post my current favorite, since my tastes are constantly changing.

I smoked a MC #4 the other night and I couldn't believe they used to be my go-to cigar. Don't get me wrong, it was great. but sooo rich, like a chocolate covered ice cream sunday. good for an occasional treat, but I would get absolutely sick of them within a week if I tried to smoke them daily now.

Re: Just One Cigar
 

This thread popped up a month or so ago and my answer is still the same...

CAO MX3

Re: Just One Cigar
 

I have to agree with others in this thread that it doesnt matter how good a certain cigar is, I would get bored with it relatively quickly

Re: Just One Cigar
 

:r:r

I would have to say an age Upmann #1

Re: Just One Cigar
 

Esencia. :tu

Re: Just One Cigar
 

Sorry, I don't see the point?

I smoke a variety of cigars, for different occasions/foods/drinks/moods lead to different tastes.

And what I like today, I may not like 5 years from now.

I don't even have only one favorite.

Re: Just One Cigar
 

So are you guys saying that you don't believe in hypothetical questions?

Re: Just One Cigar
 

The Original Master Blend!

Because I think it's a damn good cigar!

Re: Just One Cigar
 

Davidoff Château D'Yquem. Not that I've ever had one. But since we're speaking hypothetically here....

Realistically, though, it might have to be a well-aged Partagas 8-9-8.

Re: Just One Cigar
 

:tpd:

Re: Just One Cigar
 

Hmmmmm, not sure what I would do here. I guess I might go with a cigar that I KNOW I like every time, like a AF Hemingway Classic. Or, maybe a WOAM. Or a Tatuaje Unicos.

Or, perhaps I would go with a stick that, when in a new humidor at a B&M, I reach for because I enjoy them so much, like a VSG. Or, maybe that stick that I reach for because I can't get it just everywhere, like a Davidoff Millineum Blend . . .

Can't do it. Can't choose just one.

Re: Just One Cigar
 

:tu My Choice!:banger

Re: Just One Cigar
 

Any Padron.

Re: Just One Cigar
 

Padron 26 #9 :tu

Re: Just One Cigar
 

Davidoff 3000 because it's the best cigar I've had to date. I curse landhoney (Seth) on a regular basis for gifting it to me. :D

Re: Just One Cigar
 

:tpd: But, the one cigar that has never failed to please, no matter what, is Don Diego; they're creamy, smooth and as I'm also a cigarette smoker, I can inhale them, which opens up a whole range of pallet notes. I'm dying to try their Privada No.2 maddies! I assume that I can smoke different vitloas? :ss

Re: Just One Cigar
 

No contest: PAM Exclusivo

Re: Just One Cigar
 

My favorite changes all the time; right now I am liking the AF Hemingways and Padrons. If I had to pick one it would be the Padron Family Reserve 45th Maduro.

Re: Just One Cigar
 

1492, Habanos 1994 or Partagas 150 Nro.109.
Go big or go home.:ss

Re: Just One Cigar
 

Boli PC for me

Re: Just One Cigar
 

Habanos 1994

Re: Just One Cigar
 

Punch DC

Re: Just One Cigar
 

AF Hemingway Signature. If it's the only one ever again, I've got to go with the one I've found to be most consistent.

Re: Just One Cigar
 

Playing along with the hypothetical, this would be my choice as well.

Re: Just One Cigar
 

In this perfect hypothetical world, I would have to choose Padron Anniversary 1964 Maduro Torpedo. It's a nice smooth smoke with a lot of flavor for me.

But, I've recently been introduced to CC's for the first time in my life (Thanks S.H.I.T. heads). They're a different animal entirely! So, if you were to ask me this question again in a month or two, I might have a different answer.

Re: Just One Cigar
 

Party Shorts, with about a year and a half/two years' age. (I.e. out of the sick period and back to normal).

Not only do I not get tired of them, when I finish one I have to fight myself not to start up another! :D

Re: Just One Cigar
 

Padron 44th

Re: Just One Cigar
 

I'd go with AF Hemi Signature maduro.
Very consistent and tasty cigar.

A close second is PAM and,
third either Ashton VSG or San Cristobal.

subject to change, of course.

Chemyst :cool2:

Re: Just One Cigar
 

Made my short-list, too. :tu

Re: Just One Cigar
 

BBF...but I'd have to have enough of them that they could be aged in rotation so I'm never without one that doesn't have a least a year or more on it...

Re: Just One Cigar
 

said the same thing a million times before, and it ain't sexy or expensive or impossible to find:

Rocky Patel Sungrown PC - usually smokes these in the factory select bundles, and to me, its what I think of when I want a flat out F*cking CIGAR...this blend tastes like what a cigar should taste like IMO, and the construction/draw has been perfect on every one.

Re: Just One Cigar
 

LCG #4 or maybe a Boli CE

Re: Just One Cigar
 

psd4 when it is on

Re: Just One Cigar
 

Some great cigars being proclaimed here (and some that are new to me).

Re: Just One Cigar
 

Partagas Series D #4

Perfect flavor and size