Originally Posted by Bill86 (Post 1002911)

Sorry to hear the reserva real wasn't good, sure it wasn't a dud? LOVE that cigar.

Would also like to add

for now
Graycliff G2
Tat - Red Tubo

I think they were duds....only time will tell.

Originally Posted by sevans105 (Post 1002755)

I officially had my WORST cigar today. Ordered a box off of Famous. Decent reviews online, very reasonable price...paid about 45 for a box of 20.

Carinos Maduro Churchill.

Should have known it was gonna be weird when I cut it and the wrapper and the filler were VERY different colors. Definitely a dyed maduro. Very bitter upon lighting, and NEVER EVER EVER got better. I kept hoping, kept giving it the benefit of the doubt. BLEH. Actually lit up the nub of a cigar I had smoked earlier that day to get the taste out of my mouth.

Learned my lesson. You get what you pay for. Dang it. I hate learning that lesson.

Originally Posted by 688sonarmen (Post 1002909)

Famous 3000 are the exception to the rule, give em a try if you have not allready:tu

Originally Posted by DaBear (Post 1003145)

CAO La Traviata. Maybe I just got a bad one, but barely made it halfway through the stick before I couldn't stand it anymore. There was no draw with how loose it was, the flavor just tasted harsh and like heat, and the burn wasn't great.

Originally Posted by nayslayer (Post 1006677)

Ha, I like the guy so thought i'd try his smokes and picked up a 4 pack of George Lopez Tonight sticks...at this point, the worst stick i've had, maybe some age will help, who knows

Originally Posted by smelvis (Post 1007664)

Any Gran habano so far that I have tried.

Originally Posted by Yardgnome (Post 1006559)

Anything Perdomo, I've tried 10-12 of them and they just don't taste good to me.

Originally Posted by RevSmoke (Post 1007035)

A comic makes a cigar line --- and you thought it would be good? :confused:

(OK, so it was an attempt at humor.

Originally Posted by Ferrari5180 (Post 1008124)

I have smoked the #3, #5 and Factory 2nds and I have liked them all quite a bit.

Originally Posted by Emjaysmash (Post 1009058)

Dang, I would smoke a lot of the aforementioned cigars with a smile on my face! Kinda fun to see what people dislike!

Originally Posted by Ratters (Post 1009217)

Ha, I'd like to see you smoke The Egg with a smile on your face! :ss

Originally Posted by Ratters (Post 1003148)

Toss up between the Free Cuba and the Drew Estate Egg Maduro. Well, I only dry heaved the Free Cuba, I actually threw up smoking the Egg, so, probably the Egg.

Originally Posted by nick2021 (Post 1006939)

Graycliff Espresso PG...had two and didn't care for them. Maybe they needed rest, dunno. It's the only thing holding me back from trying the double espresso.

Originally Posted by TheDudeAbides (Post 1015422)

The best way i can describe the flavor would be to have ya'll imagine licking the arse of one of those famous racing toads Mark Twain wrote about, just after it had finished a race across a pig pen, rendering plant, hospital waste dump, and an open sewer outside an Indian food restaurant.

Originally Posted by Ferrari5180 (Post 1007095)

I would have to say Rocky Patel's Cameroon Especial. These things just were not in my alley. Anyhow, if you want to have a goo laugh, check this video out. I saw it the other day and I could not stop laughing.

http://www.stogiereview.com/2007/03/...imited-ligero/

Originally Posted by Evonnida (Post 1017651)

not my picture, but the worst I've had was a Taboo Twist
http://www.aspiringgentleman.com/wp-...3/IMG_1901.jpg
Also up there was a 5 Vegas Cask Strength. That one was my fault though as we were at a party and the cigar was sitting outside in WAY too much humidity. It was wet when I tried to smoke it...

Originally Posted by hscmit (Post 1017742)

I really didnt like the AB family blend, 90+ rating my ass. Gave it two tries too, just so I could be fair

Originally Posted by Ewingrules (Post 1017508)

Perdomo anything, I just can't get into any cigar in this line.:(

Originally Posted by hscmit (Post 1017742)

I really didnt like the AB family blend, 90+ rating my ass. Gave it two tries too, just so I could be fair

Originally Posted by DBall (Post 1013496)

Cigar #3

http://i725.photobucket.com/albums/w...x/CIMG0402.jpg

This cigar is a f***ing beast. 52 RG, over 6” long. The people I meet with weekly would get a huge kick out of me smoking something so uncharacteristically large…

1st/3rd:

Pre light draw is pretty much too easy… this thing is like a straw. A really, really fat straw. Lighting it and starting out, I’m really not getting anything from this flavor-wise at the very beginning. Just smoke. Blech… at this point I wonder if I’ll even be able to finish this thing. It’s the flavor of burning leaves being sucked through a big, fat straw.

Oh god… this is bad. I swear I just got chlorine, like I accidently got water in my mouth at a YMCA pool.

If it weren’t for the awful flavors that occasionally appear, there would be none.

2nd/3rd:

http://i725.photobucket.com/albums/w...x/CIMG0403.jpg

I figure this can’t get much worse, so I decided to pair it with a nice tall cup of bleach. The burning in my gullet and the feeling of corroding esophageal lining and stomach tissue offsets the pungent, acrid smoke this atrocity spews forth.

I am wondering if the Mr. Yuk sticker is on the box this came from. Smoking this makes me feel like Kermit in the “Sad Kermit – Hurt” video (look that up on youtube at your own risk… if you have a truly demented sense of humor, you may laugh quite a bit. I’d almost call it NSFW, but it is a muppet, after all…).

My throat feels like I swallowed a pitchfork. I don’t hate myself enough to finish this.

http://i725.photobucket.com/albums/w...x/CIMG0404.jpg


Score: -5,452,805,013 out of 10. This should be used as a method of torture… it tastes like unbridled sorrow.

Originally Posted by Jbailey (Post 953376)

El Baton.

I felt like I went to a garbage dump and sucked on the incinerator chimney.