Re: If you were Stranded, ONLY I CIGAR.
 

Lp t52

Re: If you were Stranded, ONLY I CIGAR.
 

And of all the others that have posted, you'd pick mine out to save? Why?

Re: If you were Stranded, ONLY I CIGAR.
 

Cause you're a punk. :D
;)

Re: If you were Stranded, ONLY I CIGAR.
 

Boy, do I feel the love.

Re: If you were Stranded, ONLY I CIGAR.
 

You know, I take that back. I want mine to be a Litto Gomez Small Batch #2.

Re: If you were Stranded, ONLY I CIGAR.
 

Hmm, on 3rd thought, maybe the Mag50.

Re: If you were Stranded, ONLY I CIGAR.
 

Oooooor, the Cabaiguan Robusto Extra?

Re: If you were Stranded, ONLY I CIGAR.
 

But, then again, there's the ...

...oh yeah, only one cigar.

Guess what, I pack up all my cigars and go home. I'm not going to play this game. :D

Re: If you were Stranded, ONLY I CIGAR.
 

Cuban Classic 1779 man i love them..

Re: If you were Stranded, ONLY I CIGAR.
 

I'm feeling the Edge boxes of 100, just because they're decent and that would give me 10,000 cigars to last me a looong time.

Re: If you were Stranded, ONLY I CIGAR.
 

I thought you used to be an Anejo whore? That's why I jabbed ya in the first place. I was just trying to shake you back to your senses. :)

Re: If you were Stranded, ONLY I CIGAR.
 

Hmm. I'm going to have to go with a regular production Stick here.

Though I've never had one (an original release that is), I'm gonna go out on a limb and say this is a good choice.
How about some original release VR Don Alejandros

Re: If you were Stranded, ONLY I CIGAR.
 

:tpd: yeah that works for me too.

Re: If you were Stranded, ONLY I CIGAR.
 

Padron 1964 Anniversary Exclusivo maduro, the 80th may replace that if I actually smoke one.

Re: If you were Stranded, ONLY I CIGAR.
 

I don't know Bill, I like the Exclusivo better than the Padron Family Reserve No. 45 Maduro and that was cA's top cigar of 2009 and a $25 stick.

Hard for me to imagine the 80th topping it but then again, I haven't had one...




Yet. :ss

Re: If you were Stranded, ONLY I CIGAR.
 

Tat T110. No Question

Re: If you were Stranded, ONLY I CIGAR.
 

I'd go with Hoya de Nicaragua " Antanos 1970 " in the big Gran Perfecto size. Who cares if I ever get rescued.

Re: If you were Stranded, ONLY I CIGAR.
 

No, I was never an Anejo whore. Context, always context. Remember, Scripture interprets Scripture.

So, the issue/context was the exaltation of Opus X, and my comment was that I thought the Anejo was a much better cigar than that Opus. I do like the Anejo, they are wonderful. I enjoy them very much, but they are not an everyday smoke for me. They are too rich to smoke very day - even if they were free.

Hope that clears up that misunderstanding.

Peace of the Lord be with you.

Re: If you were Stranded, ONLY I CIGAR.
 

Psd4

Re: If you were Stranded, ONLY I CIGAR.
 

Tat RC233

Re: If you were Stranded, ONLY I CIGAR.
 

Noella Reserva

Re: If you were Stranded, ONLY I CIGAR.
 

That's the beauty of it. I already know you're not an anejo whore, too.
I just love propagating that myth. :D
I got a kick out of you getting called an Anejo whore, too.
I agree completely about Opus/Anejo, although I think Opus are total poop. You're just a nicer guy about it than me. Plus you have a lot more patience with subpar smokes than I do. I aspire to that. :tu

Re: If you were Stranded, ONLY I CIGAR.
 

Patience with subpar smoke? Not like I used to. Now they get one opportunity, if it is something everybody is raving about - maybe a second chance. But no more than that.

Now, there is a marca out there that I want to try more of, but is cost prohibitive - Litto Gomez. There are a couple other marcas that have impressed me enough that I will be getting more of as time goes on, to see if they are as worthy as I believe they might be - Kristoff and J.Fuego.

But are any of these worthy to be my 1 smoke if it was all I could have? Not yet.

Re: If you were Stranded, ONLY I CIGAR.
 

this would be my choice

Re: If you were Stranded, ONLY I CIGAR.
 

I have yet to find a cigar that I would enjoy exclusively for the rest of my life!!!

I enjoy variety and change!!!

If I have to pick, I say Illusione ~2~!!!:tu

I would also like a giant walk in humidor, torch lighter, butane, some great beverages, and food would be a plus!!! :tu

Re: If you were Stranded, ONLY I CIGAR.
 

That still makes you more patient than me, my brother. :)
My alley is strewn with cigars that got maybe a half inch to an inch to "come around". I won't even force myself to endure an expensive smoke if it doesn't come around in 15 minutes. I DEFINATELY won't go back for a number two. That's great that you do it the way you do. I rely on your input because I know you take a good hard look. I don't have to because you do my due diligence. Saves me grief. :D
You're in luck, too, brother. I have a few 2006 Litto's left and just got a couple boxes of 09 Oscuros. If mind serves me, I have some old Kristoff's, but I think I looked for them once and couldn't find them. No clue where they got to.
Got a couple boxes of #46 Anejos today, too. I'm kinda overloaded with Anejos, really.
I figure you're gonna give me crap for sending you cigars again, but I don't really care. You spread the joy that is cigars, and you are very well equipped to do it. That's priceless, my friend. You asked why I pick on you. There ya have it. :tu

Re: If you were Stranded, ONLY I CIGAR.
 

Why do a get a sinking feeling in the pit of my gut after reading this post? :confused: The words, "resistance if futile" seem to run through my head. I wonder if it is too late to move to ... (oh yeah, if I say here, what's the point of moving)

Re: If you were Stranded, ONLY I CIGAR.
 

opus #2 would be fine with me!

Re: If you were Stranded, ONLY I CIGAR.
 

I can see why, Anejos are a damn tasty stick! :tu

I haven't tried the Litto Gomez yet but I did grab some LFD Cabinet Oscuros last week and they are really nice!!!

:ss

Re: If you were Stranded, ONLY I CIGAR.
 

50ct boxes of Mag46s

Re: If you were Stranded, ONLY I CIGAR.
 

noella

Re: If you were Stranded, ONLY I CIGAR.
 

Barring holy grail smokes I'd have to go for something in a fifty cab, RASS comes to mind at first, but I would get more smoking time with Party Lusitanias.

Re: If you were Stranded, ONLY I CIGAR.
 

Tough question but the only thing I can think of that I know I would be able to absolutely count on consistency and something that I would probably always enjoy in my mind would have to be anything out of the LFD Double Ligero or even Ligero lines. Probably either the L300 Cabinet or the Oscuro Especial.

Re: If you were Stranded, ONLY I CIGAR.
 

2004 Cohiba Sublimes

Re: If you were Stranded, ONLY I CIGAR.
 

NC would Anejo 46

CC Sig V

Re: If you were Stranded, ONLY I CIGAR.
 

50-cab Ninfas

Re: If you were Stranded, ONLY I CIGAR.
 

No 80's Davi's, you gonna settle on 46's

Re: If you were Stranded, ONLY I CIGAR.
 

100 boxes of 1958 Dunhill's

Re: If you were Stranded, ONLY I CIGAR.
 

Don't mind me, just responding to old posts :sl

Re: If you were Stranded, ONLY I CIGAR.
 

I know it's old but what the heck,

Oliva Master Blend #1 Toropedo :dr

Re: If you were Stranded, ONLY I CIGAR.
 

Oliva Masterblends 1 in Churchill.

Re: If you were Stranded, ONLY I CIGAR.
 

ILLUSIONE Cg4. Out of everything that I've tried so far this is the best. IMO better than My Father, Padron 1964 Maduro, Tats, and many more. A close second would be LG 9.

Re: If you were Stranded, ONLY I CIGAR.
 

Good question. I don't have enough experience with cigars in general to pick one to smoke into perpetuity. But from my limited experience, either sig ii's that are on, trini Reyes, or sig vi's.

Hopefully if I'm stranded on the island in question, that I have adequate storage accommodations for that many sticks.

Re: If you were Stranded, ONLY I CIGAR.
 

I'd probably have Montecristo Churchill for the entire stay in that Island.

Re: If you were Stranded, ONLY I CIGAR.
 

Wow, big jump from February to August.

I'd probably take 100 boxes of Tatuaje Miami Noellas or Anejo 46. I love both cigars.

I have been leaning more and more towards the Tats.

Re: If you were Stranded, ONLY I CIGAR.
 

Tobacco leaf salad, brother. All the food you need.

Re: If you were Stranded, ONLY I CIGAR.
 

Probably not anyone's choice, but I would do a Zino Platinum chubby....I could smoke 10 of them a day

Re: If you were Stranded, ONLY I CIGAR.
 

'09 Cohiba Sig IIs

Re: If you were Stranded, ONLY I CIGAR.
 

Punch DCs, but if somebody replaced them with Monte Esps or RAGs, I wouldn't whine too much.

Re: If you were Stranded, ONLY I CIGAR.
 

I haven't smoked enough to answer this correctly, but as of right now it will be KRISTOFF