Re: What Is My Favorite Cigar?
 

A Churchill with Chin nuts?? :sh

Re: What Is My Favorite Cigar?
 

Hey, the old Bahia Brazilian maduros, the ones with the yellow band, weren't half-bad with some age on them.

But yeah, it was a joke.

Re: What Is My Favorite Cigar?
 

Those lovely Oliva Blue Cloth band Os... :dr :dr :dr :dr

Re: What Is My Favorite Cigar?
 

Bolivar PC.
I was thinking the Gold Medal until you mentioned "plain old off the shelf stuff"

Re: What Is My Favorite Cigar?
 

Swisher Sweet? :confused: ;s

Re: What Is My Favorite Cigar?
 

Padron 1964 Anny

or



http://scene7.samsclub.com/is/image/..._size_380x380$

Re: What Is My Favorite Cigar?
 

Mac got the two nc's. JJ Maduros and Oliva Blues.
Peter, I do love Boli GM's. They're pretty much off the shelf.

Re: What Is My Favorite Cigar?
 

Bolivar CJ or RASCC.

Re: What Is My Favorite Cigar?
 

Negatory, Admiral.

Re: What Is My Favorite Cigar?
 

The best ones I ever had were from '09, if that helps.

Re: What Is My Favorite Cigar?
 

Monte 2?

Re: What Is My Favorite Cigar?
 

No, but I do like Monte 4's and 5's.

Another clue...
Most guys like the bigger ones from '98. I like 'em too, but they're too rich for my blood.

Re: What Is My Favorite Cigar?
 

HdM du Gourmet

Re: What Is My Favorite Cigar?
 

Romeo y Julietta Short Churchill

Re: What Is My Favorite Cigar?
 

Siglo IV

Re: What Is My Favorite Cigar?
 

LGC's MdO 2

Re: What Is My Favorite Cigar?
 

The NC is Indian Tabac, is it not?
(Disclosure - I remember years ago you did an experiment
with these, and I was one of the guinea pigs)

Oh, never mind, didn't read the prior posts.

Re: What Is My Favorite Cigar?
 

There ya go. When they're good.
But I ALWAYS love Trini Reyes and PLpc's.