Re: Old Faithful....
 

Love me some Punch Gran Puro.

Re: Old Faithful....
 

:tpd:

Sometimes called the Punch Rothschild Oscuro - same same.

Re: Old Faithful....
 

:tpd:

Also like the Magnum.

Taboo Twist Toro and CAO Italia Piazza are my other go to's.

Re: Old Faithful....
 

Olivia Serie G always does me right. :)

Re: Old Faithful....
 

any Padron
CAO Brazilia
Camacho SLR

these NC are my go to the CAO holds a a place in my heart as it was the 1st cigar I smoked. As far as gerbils I have had a few but mostly BOLIVAR PETIT CORONAS
:2

Re: Old Faithful....
 

601 Red Robusto :tu

Re: Old Faithful....
 

Padron and Boli Pcs. :tu

Re: Old Faithful....
 

Camacho Corojo. Hands down. ALWAYS a good smoke.

Re: Old Faithful....
 

:tpd:

Re: Old Faithful....
 

Punch Rare Corojo and Partegas Black...always been good. :tu

Re: Old Faithful....
 

NC - DPG Blue corona corda
CC - Party 898

Re: Old Faithful....
 

Don Peppin blue label..

Re: Old Faithful....
 

Easy for me... AF Hemingway Short Story...

Re: Old Faithful....
 

Tatuaje Noellas have always given me the flavor and quality I crave. It's closely followed by Oliva V Belicoso's which are always consistent.

Re: Old Faithful....
 

My thought is,"we are in a pretty good place in time as far as NC cigars are concerned".
Faithful cigars are many imo...
AF 858
AF SG's(many more AF)
Padron...period.
have not had a bad...
DPG's
illusione
Punch Rare Corojo
Cabaiguan
601
Ashton VSG's
and the list goes on.
Whatever cigar mood I'm in,I know exactly how each if these will taste and perform.
All Old Faithfuls in my book :tu

Re: Old Faithful....
 

There are a lot of cigars that don't are good EVERYTIME I smoke them. There are also cigars that only dissapoint me sometimes... Its all a toss up, since tobacco is a variable product.
Scott